January 06, 2007

Another Reason Businesses Should Host Blogs: Millard and infoUSA

According to DMNews, Linda McAleer has retired from multichannel list firm Millard.

How does this relate to blogs? When I analyze my visitor information, I can see the search terms that bring people to my site. The search terms, when viewed in a broader context, suggest change at Millard, an infoUSA company.

There are numerous reasons why businesses should blog. If the blogger does a good job of search engine optimization, s/he will be able to understand industry inflection points via search terms. This picture into the future gives you a competitive advantage, assuming your SEO techniques are solid. I am not implying my techniques are solid. I continue to learn.

Who Is Your Customer?

Sometimes Database Marketers have to ask themselves who their customer really is?

Maybe you just went through a lousy holiday season. You evaluate the business, and realize you are not going to meet sales and profit expectations. Furthermore, your business has too much inventory, and has to move it now!!!

You gather for your weekly Executive meeting. The Inventory Executive wants to add a series of e-mail campaigns to your very best customers, featuring failed products at dramatically marked-down prices. The Inventory Executive also wants to send a 're-mail' of a holiday catalog, changing the creative on the cover and back page, marking down the merchandise by sixty to seventy percent.

The Chief Merchant likes this idea, because if frees-up her 'open to buy', so she can get fresh, compelling product in the door. The CFO has mixed feelings, wanting to move merchandise and increase sales, not wanting markdowns that are so steep as to further erode profit. The COO likes the idea, because she may have to cut hours for employees at the distribution center because sales are not meeting expectations.

The Chief Marketing Officer does not like the idea, because customer research indicates customers are fed up with being pummeled by catalogs and e-mail spam. She wants to know why customers, who are tired of being clobbered with marketing, should receive more marketing about products they didn't care for during the holiday season? Her advocation of the customer is not welcomed. Her comments are considered 'theoretical' and 'impractical', given the problems the business currently faces.

We Database Marketers have many 'customers'. We have to please the Inventory Executive, and send out enough marketing to high-spending customers to meet his needs. We have to please the Chief Merchant by giving her the opportunity to bring in new merchandise. We have to please the CFO by minimizing the damage to the profit and loss statement. We have to please the COO, who does not want to cut hours for great employees. We have to please the CMO, who tries to advocate on behalf of the customer.

Our job is one of 'optimization with constraints'. In this case, we have to move merchandise, constrained to the needs of each executive, and our customers. No answer is right, no answer pleases everybody.

How about you? In your job, do you have to deal with conflict between internal and external customers? How do you deal with these conflicts?

January 05, 2007

A 15 Year Old Analyst Running Circles Around The Rest Of Us

Those of us in the Database Marketing field are on the verge of losing our deathgrip on customer information.

As an example, take the blog Yuvisense, hosted by Yuvi, a fifteen year old in India. Recently, Yuvi decided to analyze information about uber-blogger Robert Scoble's blog. This link is the second of his posts about Scoble's blog.

Two topics come to mind.

First, who are you going to hire, the twenty-six year old who mails you a resume, touting the three years of experience at a great company, or Yuvi, the person who had the initiative at age fifteen to unabashedly share his analytical insights about a uber-blogger with the entire world, illustrating a clarity of presentation that most forty year olds cannot aspire to?

Second, pretend you are the Vice President of Database Marketing at a company like Talbots, J. Jill, Williams Sonoma, J.C. Penney, J. Crew, or any other company that starts with a J. In time, which option makes more sense?

Option #1 = Hire bright analytical minds, competing against companies like Google or Yahoo! on the basis of salary, benefits, stock options and prestige.

Option #2 = Farm out Database Marketing to Abacus or any number of competitors.

Option #3 = Make your analyses available to a throng of eager analytical bloggers, offering prize money to the individual who develops an acceptable answer, and a stipend to other individuals who invest time in the solution.

In time, I can see a world where folks like Yuvi access corporate datasets with anonymous information, creating brilliant insights and analyses that cannot possibly be matched by in-house talent. And what an interesting opportunity this presents for both businesses and individuals.

I subscribed to Yuvi's RSS feed. Let's see where Yuvi, and thousands of other bright, enterprising analytical minds take the field of Database Marketing.

January 04, 2007

Best E-Mail Contact Strategy? You Decide

You are the marketer at a multichannel retailer. You decide to survey your customers about your e-mail practices, because pundits suggest that customers are now in control over your marketing activities.

Your customers surprise you. Instead of the one e-mail campaign you send them each week, customers overwhelmingly tell you they want a monthly e-mail, and maybe three additional campaigns for major sales events.

You eagerly set up a three month test, to understand the financial impact of the strategy your customers advocate. The results below are extrapolated to represent an entire year of campaigns.

E-Mail Test Results, Annualized To Total Housefile




52 E-Mails 15 E-Mails

Per Year Per Year



Average List Size = 100,000


Average Open Rate 20.00% 25.00%
Average Click-Through 30.00% 33.00%
Average Conversion Rate 3.50% 3.80%
Purchase Rate 0.21% 0.31%
Average Order Size $230 $235
Sales per E-Mail $0.48 $0.74



Total Net Sales $2,511,600 $1,105,088
Gross Margin $1,255,800 $552,544
Less Marketing Cost $15,600 $4,500
Less Pick/Pack/Ship $376,740 $165,763
Variable Operating Profit $863,460 $382,281

Pundits want you to let customers take charge of your marketing activities. In this case, you survey your customers, and they tell you they want fifteen e-mail campaigns a year. You test the strategy, and find out it will cost you nearly a half-million dollars of profit.

Let's assume that your CFO demands that you generate profit increases, not decreases. Let's assume you do not have the capabilities to tailor the e-mail strategy to the individual e-mail address.

What do you do? Do you listen to your customer, and convince your CFO that the customer is right, and the shareholders/owners are wrong? Or, do you ignore the feedback of your customers? I'm going to guess that you aim to please your CFO.

Five Things You Don't Know About Me Meme

The Five Things You Don't Know About Me Meme, started by Jeff Pulver on December 10, has made its way to The MineThatData Blog. Thanks to Friends Of MineThatData blogger Becky Carroll at Customers Rock! for the ping.

For those of you who are interested, I appear to be the 16th generation of this game of tag, since inception. I was referred by Becky, who was referred by Derrick Daye at BrandingStrategyInsider.com,.

Derrick was referred by a series of folks who write about SEO and online marketing, including Shimon Sandler at ShimonSandler.com, who was referred by Gordon Choi at GordonChoi.com, who was referred by Vinny Lingham at VinnyLingham.com,

We move into Affiliate Marketing next, with Jeremy Palmer at QuitYourDayJob.com, who was referred by Scott Jangro at Jangro.com, who was referred by Sam Harrelson at SamHarrelson.com, who was referred by online marketer Jim Kukral at Jim Kukral.com, who was referred by Shmuly at OneParkAvenueReality.com.

This referral came from the Affiliate and Search Engine Marketing world of Kristopher B. Jones at Pepperjamblog.com, who was referred by online marketer Jeremy Schoemaker at Shoemoney.com. Moving right along, Jeremy was referred by internet marketing consultant Andy Beal at Marketingpilgrim.com. Andy was referred by Friends of MineThatData blogger Avinash Kaushik at Occam's Razor. Wow!

But we're not done yet. Avinash was referred by South Africa's Dave Gale at DigitalPilgrim. And Dave picked up the meme from the originator, Jeff Pulver.

Because of that series of antics, you get to learn Five Things You Didn't Know About Me.


Number Five: I am an avid fan of Sprint Car Racing, and to a lesser extent, NASCAR racing. There is almost nothing I would rather do than spend a summer Saturday evening at the Grays Harbor Raceway in Elma, or the Skagit Speedway in Burlington, watching twenty-four Sprint Cars kick up dirt and belch exhaust during a 40 lap A-Main. I know, start rolling your eyes, I come by this quite honestly. My father raced cars in his twenties. Our family tradition was to attend Saturday evening races at the quarter mile dirt track in Plymouth, WI, when I was a child. It's in my blood.

Number Four: I have a passion for nachos that is unparalleled. I'm not talking about the kind of nachos where chips are baked with shredded cheddar, salsa, ground beef and any other add-ons. Instead, I am talking about forty chips in a cardboard container, with fake molten cheese generously drizzled over the surface of the salty delights. Add a 44 ounce Mountain Dew and Sprint Car races, and you're approaching MineThatData nirvana.

Number Three: My favorite move of all time is 'Less Than Zero', closely followed by 'Peggy Sue Got Married'. Oh sure, you can argue that features like 'Forrest Gump' performed better at the box office, but few movies called out the problems of the mid-80s college-bound crowd better than 'Less Than Zero'.

Number Two: I am one of maybe twenty-seven people who avidly follow Book TV on CSPAN2. CSPAN2 videotapes author presentations at various book stores (non-fiction), and broadcasts them each Saturday and Sunday. Check your local cable or satellite provider for details.

Number One: I've made a lot of mistakes during my career. None were more glaring than a Fall 1995 mistake at Lands' End. It was my job to pick the 1,000,000 best households for a women's catalog. I was asked to pick an additional 300,000 households as a contingency. So I picked the best 1,300,000 households. Then, I sorted the households in ascending order of value, instead of descending order. Instead of the best 1,000,000 households being mailed, I mailed households 300,001 to 1,300,000. When the book was mailed, we instantly knew there was a problem, because the mailing was missing expectations by forty percent. I investigated my code, found the error, and fessed-up to the problem. We sent a catalog to the 300,000 great customers that I failed to mail, at a cost of $200,000. Thank goodness my salary wasn't garnished. From that point forward, I became a zealot for audited, accurate, correct information.

If these Friends of MineThatData wish to participate, feel free: Anthony Power, Adelino de Almeida, David Raab, Dirk Plantiga, Jeff Larche.

January 03, 2007

Home Depot CEO Takes Home $210,000,000 Severance Package

By now, you've heard the sad story of Bob Nardelli, the CEO of Home Depot who resigned on Wednesday. His severance package will yield him $210,000,000.

Please remember, his board of directors had to approve this package. Also keep in mind that the amount of revenue and profit this business generates is beyond staggering. In the last fiscal year, Home Depot generated nearly $82,000,000,000 (that's eighty-two billion) net sales, and $9,300,000,000 in pre-tax profit. Yes, that's right, 9.3 billion, pre-tax.

A severance package of $210,000,000 barely registers against $9.3 billion in pre-tax profit. Only mega-companies can offer mega-compensation.

If you are wondering how this hurts the 380,000 employees who made all of this possible, here's how. Take $210,000,000 / 380,000 = $552. Ultimately, each employee contributed $552 to Mr. Nardelli's good fortune. A half-time employee making $12 an hour sacrifices just shy of five percent of her salary supporting CEO severance.

There's only one way to stop this, folks. Stop shopping at Home Depot. As long as we keep shopping at mega-stores, mega-profits will drive mega-severance packages. We are part of the problem.

Alan Rimm-Kaufman on Holiday PPC

Alan frequently offers his readers valuable information, providing insights into customer behavior without giving up proprietary secrets. He has a good post on Holiday PPC over at his blog. Give it a quick read.

An Ecommerce Brand Is Constantly Reinventing Itself

A year or two ago I received an email ... the Leader asked "what happened to all of those COVID customers, it's like they just disa...