January 18, 2015

Omnichannel Rob Lowe

For those of you who still watch television, you can't spend a half-hour without seeing a Rob Lowe DirecTV commercial. Click here if you're reading in email for an example ... or watch below if you're reading via the website / RSS.



The script is simple ... and can be applied to the omnichannel movement.


Rob Lowe: "Hi, I'm Rob Lowe, and I buy stuff."

Omnichannel Rob Lowe (Holding A Tablet, A Mobile Phone, And A Laptop): "And I'm Omnichannel Rob Lowe, and I love shopping via devices."

Rob Lowe: "I like shopping at companies that have merchandise that I want to purchase."

Omnichannel Rob Lowe (Accidentally dropping his laptop on the floor): "And I like shopping at companies that allow me to access my shopping cart anywhere, anytime."

Rob Lowe: "Fact: If a company has something I want to purchase, I just purchase the item."

Omnichannel Rob Lowe: "Fact: If an influential blogger won't pin an item on Pinterest that is shared via Twitter with a hashtag and then is available for eight seconds on Snapchat and then is given a thousand thumbs up on Facebook and is then featured in retargeting ads 1,443 times per day on every website I visit and then is available online and in stores so that I can drive to a store and try on the item and then not buy the item in-store but instead have the item shipped to my home next-day from a neighboring store, shipped for free of course, I won't purchase the item. Because this is what the customer demands, right?"

Rob Lowe (pointing at Omnichannel Rob Lowe, who is grumbling that his shopping carts are not updating in real time across his laptop, mobile phone, and tablet): "Don't be like this 'me'. Drop your omnichannel habits, and just buy the stupid item, now.


Yes, this is a light-hearted tease ... I fully understand that customers use multiple devices to shop, I get it. I think it's important to point out what we are communicating ... we are telling customers to act in a complicated manner to complete simple tasks. We can spend more time simplifying shopping ... and if we did, maybe, just maybe, customers would spend more.

January 15, 2015

New Subs and Unsubs

In case you haven't noticed, I am in the process of running a three month long test here on this blog.

In much of November / December, I shifted the focus to retail, and to omnichannel.

In January, I am working through a fictional company (Hippoman's Big And Tall), and will continue to do so for another few weeks.

Here's what happens when I conduct experiments.

  1. New subs double or triple.
  2. Unsubs double or triple.
  3. The increased buzz/velocity results in more subs.
I'd like your feedback.

What, in your opinion, is the appropriate cadence of content? Should I have themes, and if I do have themes, should I go all-in for a month, or should I intersperse the content with other content? Finally, what should the other content be?

Tell me what you think.

Hippoman's Big And Tall: Good Customers vs. New/Existing Merchandise

Last time we studied Hippoman's, we saw that productivity isn't always in decline. Summer productivity is flat, and November productivity is improving.

Let's look at productivity among 2x buyers, for new items and existing items.

Here's new items.


Ok, now we're getting somewhere, aren't we?!!

Look at January - June 2013. Productivity increased, didn't it? Customers spent more on new items.

Then we have September - December 2013. A catastrophe. New item performance cratered.

Now look at January - June 2014. Holy cow! Mr. Hippoman's team must have cut way, way, way back on new item introductions, because those kind of metrics are just catastrophic.

More on new items in a moment.

Here's the comp segment analysis for existing items.


HOLY COW! OMG! And whatever term you want to add to exclaim the reason this business is failing. We've figured out a major component of business failure, haven't we?

What do you see, when you compare this table to the comp segment analysis of new items? Study both tables closely.

In 2013, new item comps were -2%, while existing items comps were +7%.

In 2014, new item comps were -29%, while existing item comps were +4%.

Mr. Hippoman is literally starving his customer file. His merchandising team either decided to stop offering new items at historical rates, or his merchandising team decided to offer new items that customers hated. We'll have to research this trend further, no doubt about it.

This analysis - these two tables - continually reveal business challenges across my client base. New items on the merchandising side are as important as new customers are on the marketing side.

Can you see why it is so critical to run a comp segment analysis on the total business, on new items, and on existing items?

January 14, 2015

Retail Sales Decline In December

Click here for details, folks.

Ask yourself why retail sales would decline at a time when omnichannel strategies have never been stronger, gas prices are the lowest in a decade, and the weather was bearable compared to 2013?

Retail sales were down in November, too.

We are focusing on technology ... but customers don't buy technology, they buy merchandise. We need a greater focus on merchandise. It is clear, now, that customers do not want what we are selling. We cannot sell crap on a tablet or phablet - that's not the solution. We need to sell stuff our customers want to buy. 

Back to the basics.

We will fix this problem.

We will fix this problem.

Hippoman's Big And Tall: How Are Good Customers Performing?

Let's look at a comp segment analysis of 2x buyers.


Ok, this isn't all bad news, is it? Yes, there have been some bad months, horrible months really (January - June 2014, September - October 2014). But business flattened out or improved moderately in November and December. That's not so bad. We'll have to check in with Mr. Hippoman to see what happened during the Christmas season.

Notice that existing customer performance generally improved in 2013. This is very, very interesting. The total business was down by about 1% in 2013, but comp segment performance was up 3.3% in 2013. This means that there were customer acquisition and/or customer reactivation problems.

When compared to 2012, we see the following.

  • Productivity declines in January, February, April, September, October, December.
  • Flat performance in May, June, July, August.
  • Productivity gains in November.
We'll need to check in with Mr. Hippoman, to see what is happening in late Winter and early Fall. It appears that summer is flat, and November is actually experiencing productivity increases.

January 13, 2015

Hippoman's Big And Tall: Merchandise Divisions

The news has been continually bad, and will get worse.

Mr. Hippoman analyzes his business across two merchandise divisions ... Tops ... and Bottoms.

Here's the four year trend for Tops:


That's a non-stop train wreck, don't you think?

Here's the four year trend for Bottoms:


The past eighteen months haven't been pretty - but the eighteen months prior to that maintained total demand. So something was done with Bottoms during that timeframe, something that at least held things constant.

When analyzing a failing business, it is common to see different trends across merchandise divisions. Often, one merchant is experiencing more success than other merchants. This can cause bad feelings. When analyzing the business, I try to find a couple of successes, and then amplify the things that were done well. 

January 12, 2015

Hippoman's Big And Tall: Free Shipping

When a business is struggling, it's common to amp-up the promotions. Let's see if Hippoman's Big And Tall did that, as their business began to implode.

Here is annual demand, non-promotionally (no free shipping) driven:


#OMG as the kids say. Mr. Hippoman used to generate $45,000,000 a year in paid-shipping orders. Today, he generates just north of $15,000,000. Imagine the impact on profitability, folks?

Here's the graph illustrating demand from orders with free shipping.


Free shipping, once comp'd after 2012, did not help the business - while paid-shipping orders declined by several million dollars. That doesn't help the profit and loss statement, does it?

Now, I ran a couple of queries, to better understand how paid-shipping and free-shipping customers behave in the future.

  • In the next year, free-shipping customers generate 50% of their demand from free-shipping, and 50% from paid-shipping.
  • In the next year, paid-shipping customers generate 30% of their demand from free-shipping, and 70% from paid-shipping.
Yup - Mr. Hippoman is slowly training his customers to buy via free shipping.

Interestingly, free shipping customers repurchased at a 29% rate, while paid shipping customers repurchased at a 22% rate. This suggests that free shipping "works". So I ran another query, measuring the percentage of demand generated via free shipping by customer quality.

  • Next year, new customers will generate 53% of their demand from free shipping.
  • Next year, best customers will generate 60% of their demand from free shipping.
So there is a bit of a bias - it is clear that Mr. Hippoman is offering free shipping to best customers, causing best customers to repurchase. That doesn't mean that free shipping is fully responsible for the increase in repurchase rate - and given that repurchase rates are in free-fall, well, that tells us that free shipping is not truly helping.

Here's one final query. I analyzed the percentage of demand that comes from free shipping by marketing channel.
  • Telephone Orders = 50%.
  • Online Orders = 60%.
  • Email Orders = 69%.
  • Paid Search Orders = 55%.
  • Affiliate Orders = 71%.
Clearly, Mr. Hippoman uses email marketing as the primary channel to communicate free shipping to customers. Email and Affiliates then attract a discount-centric customer, and as our earlier query showed, customers become trained to purchase via free shipping.

Mr. Hippoman's team is creating a series of reinforcing negative feedback loops, don't you think?

An Ecommerce Brand Is Constantly Reinventing Itself

A year or two ago I received an email ... the Leader asked "what happened to all of those COVID customers, it's like they just disa...