February 05, 2015

NEMOA Buzzwords - Depicted Graphically

I took each session offered at NEMOA next month, and depicted the buzzwords used to describe the session in two dimensions (a Principal Components Analysis, for those of you who want to give this a try). Each buzzword had to be listed in at least three of the twenty-three sessions I graded (click on the image to read the buzzwords).



I added two words ... if a brand/client was presenting, I added the word "CLIENT" to the buzzword list ... if a vendor was presenting (as was the case in 17 of the 23 session I graded), I added the word "VENDOR" to the buzzword list.

Now, this analysis is only relevant to one conference, and is only relevant to what the conference organizers chose to focus on, and is only relevant to the copy written in the conference literature.

Regardless, I like to look at "opposites":
  • Omnichannel / Strategy / Sales is opposite of Best Practices / Merchandise.
  • Content / Traffic / Acquisition / Engagement / Brand / Digital / Customers / Catalog is opposite of Analytics / Testing / Attribution.
The opposites tell us how we think about concepts. It's hard to force testing upon somebody who cares about brand. It's hard to get folks to focus on merchandise when they are passionate about omnichannel.

If you were running this conference, you'd probably want to measure "who" attends each session ... the analysis would tell you the type of individual (Executive, Director, Manager, Analyst, Client, Vendor, Marketing, Merchandising, Creative, Online, Circulation) who cares about various topics, allowing you to craft a more interesting conference in the future.

February 04, 2015

The Story of 2015, So Far

Across the board, it's new customers.

Namely, that's for so many companies, it is getting harder and harder to acquire new customers.

In an omnichannel world with infinite channels, it has gotten much, much harder to find new customers. Ask anybody. The omnichannel playbook promises riches - the opposite is happening.
  • In retail, omnichannel advertising strategies have dissuaded customers from leaving home, causing malls to empty.
  • In catalogs, the co-ops are in the process of optimizing themselves out of business by sending the same 70 year old customers to most catalogers, greatly lowering response and limiting the overall universe.
  • In e-commerce, new customer acquisition rates are slowing (ask eBay) as Amazon overwhelms the industry and as cannibalization from catalogs/retail slowly winds down.
If your fiscal year begins on February 1, then the number one goal for your marketing team in 2015 must be to find clever strategies for finding new customers at low cost.

Period.

February 03, 2015

Co-Op Performance Is Hemorrhaging For Businesses With Customers < Age 65

Yesterday, I received two consulting inquiries, both with essentially the same request.

  • "Would you be willing to help us work with the co-ops? Could you review their modeling strategy, could you help me see why their performance has become so awful, and could you encourage the co-ops to offer the catalog industry better performance? In just a few years from now, the co-ops are going to bankrupt all of us, if this keeps up."
#OhBoy. 

Fifteen years ago, folks like Don Libey told you this was going to happen. Some of you crucified him.

I've been documenting the feedback loop since 2006.

Your list teams told you this would be trouble, but some of you helped run them out of business because you liked bellying up to the bar to purchase an oversized container of frothy names at $0.06 each.

Let's briefly review the feedback loop, so that you understand what is happening.

  • The catalog industry, as a whole, chose the co-ops as the primary source of new customers.
  • The e-commerce industry, as a whole, chose Google as the primary source of new customers.
  • The mobile industry is in the process of choosing a preferred vendor as the primary source of new customers.
  • Companies succeeding in e-commerce / mobile do not contribute their younger shoppers (age 13-44) to the co-ops. This creates a age bias in the co-op responsive universe.
  • Catalogers, meanwhile, heartily contribute their names to the co-op universe, flooding it with 60-79 year old shoppers.
  • The co-ops, of course, must optimize performance. Therefore, they send to you, the cataloger, the names "most likely to respond". Those names shop via the phone/mail (yes, mail, they mail a check, that's not a typo from 1988).
  • When the co-ops send you phone/mail shoppers or online shoppers who love buying via a catalog source code, they send you shoppers who have specific merchandise preferences.
  • Your merchandising teams, unconsciously of course, see that certain merchandise "works", and they get more of that merchandise. It turns out that this is merchandise preferred by customers age 65+ (Judy).
  • When a 45 year old customer visits your website, the 45 year old customer sees merchandise tailored to customers age 65+. The 45 year old customer does not convert, and does not respond via catalog, and who can blame that customer?
  • You, in your marketing reporting, see that younger customers have poor lifetime value. You decide that online buyers are not worth the trouble.
  • As a consequence, you embed your business even deeper into the co-op ecosystem, and continue to contribute customers age 65+ to the co-ops.
  • The co-ops receive masses of customers age 65+ from catalogers, further optimizing those names.
  • In most of my projects, customer spend begins to drop as the customer passes 72 or 73 years old.
  • In recent years, many, many names sent by the co-ops are now older than 72 or 73 years old, driving down co-op name responsiveness.
  • Catalogers are now over-targeting customers age 65+ ... a ever-decreasing audience of responsive catalog names getting mailed a comparable number of catalogs yields lower performance.
  • Meanwhile, few/none of the names in the Google / Facebook / Snapchat ecosystem enter the co-op ecosystem. The co-op ecosystem cannot be refreshed with younger names, and if it could be refreshed, it wouldn't matter, because catalogers by and large now offer a merchandise assortment tailored to a customer age 65+.
This feedback loop cannot be broken.

It's over.

We asked for this. Truly, we did.

For many catalog clients with customers > age 70, this isn't an issue (yet).

But for everybody else, this is the logical end game of a multi-step process that we couldn't see happening, because we chose to only look one step ahead.

Catalogers with a core customer base < age 65 must find new customers. This is going to be a very difficult proposition. Many catalogers find 70% or more new customers from co-ops, and the majority of co-ops are owned by corporate conglomerates who simply want your data, for free, so that they can monetize it and profit from it. 

Let that one sink in for a moment. You give them data, for free. FOR FREE! That's like vendors giving you merchandise for free so that you can profit from it. And then co-ops move your data into their ecosystem, they profit from selling your data to non-catalogers, and they profit from your data by regurgitating it and re-selling it back to you. Name a logical business person in an adjacent industry who would accept this business model?

Our industry agreed to a one-sided and now, increasingly, unprofitable business model. We did this. It's our fault.

I know - you want me to fix it. "Stop criticizing us, tell us what to do - and give us your advice for free, please."

Here's how I'd approach it ... you'll be certain to agree with parts, and hate other parts. That's ok.
  1. You have a five-year window to keep generating profit from the current ecosystem ... using co-ops to acquire 65 year old customers who love merchandise catering to 65 year old customers. Then things get difficult. So please take full advantage of your opportunity. If you love your business, love your merchandise, and love the co-ops, why not target a 75 or 80 year old customer with merchandise a 75-80 year old customer loves? Move toward an older customer. Yes. Older. Follow the customer.
  2. Otherwise, you have no choice, no choice, but to begin the process of finding a merchandise assortment that an "adjacent customer", one age 45-64, will appreciate. It may be your current merchandise assortment, it may be a similar merchandise assortment.
  3. If you wish to acquire a customer age 45-64, you'll find an adjacent merchandise assortment that is congruent with your "brand". And you will become an online marketing guru. I know, you don't want to hear this. You don't want to be an online marketing guru, you want to be a cataloger. If you want to be a cataloger, please revisit #1 above.
  4. If you don't like the idea of an "adjacent" customer and "adjacent" merchandise, consider creating a new brand. I know, this is painful and risky. But you have the infrastructure in place to be successful, right? Find merchants who understand the adjacent customer, and find online marketers who understand the adjacent customer.
  5. If you don't like #2, and you don't like #3, and you don't like #4, I encourage you to go back to #1, and follow the customer to the logical end game.
Ok, if you don't like my ideas, why not use the comments section to chart a path to the future for the catalog industry. Share your ideas, how about it?

Staples / Office Depot / Office Max

I get criticized, a lot, when I suggest that omnichannel will lead, not to sales gains, but to store closures.

And then, we hear of this little gem ... Staples may merge with Office Depot / Office Max (click here).

When Office Depot / Office Max merged, four hundred stores were scheduled to be closed (click here) ... a "unique opportunity to consolidate", as the press release said. Who doesn't crave a unique opportunity to get smaller? Or who doesn't love the opportunity to "optimize the store portfolio" (click here)? That same article outlines how employees enjoyed pay cuts following the merger ... imagine getting your pay cut at $8/hour, or at a manager's salary of $14.02 an hour? Omnichannel!!! That's some serious optimization going on!

Of course, the experts said that Staples was "poised to grab market share" in such an event (click here). Well, how did that work out? If the predictions were true, Staples wouldn't be looking to merge to accelerate further cost savings, would they?

Digital hates inefficiency.

Yes, these folks are trying to compete with Amazon and Wal-Mart.

But there is something so much deeper going on - and few of us wish to think about it, because if you think three steps ahead, you get depressed. So instead, our industry focuses on the glib concept of omnichannel, putting our hands over our ears, hoping to not hear the future coming.

The Story: Digital hates inefficiency. Digital creates price transparency. Digital creates a disincentive to get in a car and drive to a store.

  • Inefficiency.
  • Price Transparency.
  • Disincentive To Shop Stores.
For Staples / Office Depot / Office Max, the trifecta is crippling.
  • Amazon / Wal-Mart can generate profit and/or market share (often the latter) by creating "basket opportunities" ... you can buy the same 1,000 sheets of white printer paper there, but also pick up five quarts of 10w30 ... something you cannot do at a big box office supply store (hint - merchandise). This takes sales away from the big box office supply store, eroding in-store profitability.
  • Digital leads to customers not driving to a store - instead buying the items online from a big box office supply store if brand loyalty exists. This further erodes in-store profitability.
  • Digital leads to price transparency - further eroding in-store profitability.
  • This causes stores to appear unprofitable.
  • This causes mergers.
  • Mergers cause store closures.
  • Store closures cause sales declines.
  • When sales decline, sales go to Amazon / Wal-Mart, making them bigger, fueling a feedback loop that further hurts retail.
You cannot fix the feedback loop by making the in-store experience "more digital". Making the in-store experience "more digital" just accelerates the feedback loop.

Digital hates inefficiency. Ask catalogers, they'll tell you. They've been there.

We're rapidly approaching a time when I need to write a booklet about this feedback loop, because the feedback loop is not well understood, albeit painfully apparent.

February 02, 2015

Radio Shack

Oh boy (click here).

It's yet another case that omnichannel cannot solve. You could offer Radio Shack merchandise in an infinite number of channels, and it won't make a difference - Radio Shack was destined to be obliterated by technology. By "digital". The very strategy some would author to save Radio Shack (omnichannel) expedites the demise of the brand.

Digital hates inefficiency.

So it's an interesting dilemma ... digital hates inefficiency, but we're told that we have to digitize the whole business, which creates even more inefficiency and worse, pits a business like Radio Shack against infinity ... an infinite number of the same choices at an infinite number of low prices.

Worse, the omnichannel thesis focuses on pleasing the core customer ... and as we learned in cataloging, this dramatically accelerates the aging of the customer base, thereby skewing the merchandise assortment to merchandise that an aging customer base likes, which precludes younger customers from wanting to buy merchandise, which further accelerates the demise of the business.

We see it over and over and over again.

February 01, 2015

Half-Life of Browsing Data

Go run this analysis, right now:

  1. Variable = Sum Daily Visits, Next 30 Days (i.e. January).
  2. Variable = Sum Daily Visits, Past Week (last week of December).
  3. Variable = Sum Daily Visits, 8-30 Days Ago (first three weeks of December).
  4. Variable = Sum Daily Visits, 31-90 Days Ago (September - November).
  5. Variable = Sum Daily Visits, 91-365 Days Ago (January - August).
Once you create the variables, then run a regression model ... January is your dependent variable, the rest are your independent variables.

Look at the coefficients of the variables. The coefficients represent the half-life of visit data. For instance, your coefficients might look like this:
  • Last Week of December = 2.493.
  • First Three Weeks of December = 0.577.
  • September - November = 0.106.
  • January - August = 0.006.
Divide each coefficient by 2.493. This tells us the half-life of browsing data.
  • Last Week of December = 1.000.
  • First Three Weeks of December = 0.231.
  • September - November = 0.043.
  • January - August = 0.002.
In our example, browsing data eight to thirty days old is only worth 23% of the weight of browsing data from the past week.

In our example, browsing data thirty-one to ninety days old is only worth 4% of the weight of browsing data from the past week.

In our example, browsing data ninety-one to three-hundred-sixty-five days ago is only worth 0.2% of the weight of browsing data from the past week.

In other words, you'd only care about data from the past week, which is more than four times as important as data from eight-to-thirty days ago. Older data is essentially irrelevant.

You see this all the time in catalog models - your browsing data only has value on two fronts ... first, older browsing data is a negative indicator with catalog responsiveness ... and second, data in the past week is generally a positive indicator of catalog responsiveness ... but those visits quickly die off ... and in fact, they die off so fast that it is hard to act upon the data outside of a hotline program.

Larger catalogers use various website visitation attributes to fire off hotline catalogs to inactive customers - this is not necessarily a real-time situation, of course, but the data has to be updated daily to have any impact on catalog segmentation.

Half-life browsing data is very important in email marketing - many large catalogers have 5-10 versions of emails multiple times a week - they use yesterday's browsing activity to shift the segment the customer belongs to, thereby assigning the customer to one of the 5-10 versions being delivered in the next campaign.

Browsing data is only important if you accurately calculate the half-life of the data. Otherwise, you've got problems.

And Then Kevin Is Wrong

There are many times when I'm wrong ... I go into a project with pre-conceived notions of what I expect to happen, I run a series of queries, and then something unexpected happens.

Our instinct, of course, is to immediately torture the data, trying to slice and dice it in a way that yields the answer we're looking for.

Here's one example - I looked at customers with exactly three purchases in 2013, trying to measure how much customers spent in 2014, based on the number of channels they bought from in 2013, and based on the number of merchandise divisions the customer purchased from in 2013.

I didn't have much faith in the omnichannel thesis (more channels = better future value). I had tremendous faith in the merchandising thesis (more departments = better future value).

What do you see?

Channels add value if the customer only purchases from one merchandise division.

Merchandise divisions add value if the customer only purchases from one channel.

Lowest-value customers historically bought from 1 Channel / 1 Division, or bought from 3 Channels / 3 Divisions.

Lesson: Every business is different. Customers exhibit unique behaviors. You have to analyze your own data, controlling for various factors, and find the truth for your own business. In this case, my hypothesis was wrong - and instead of beating the data into submission, it's just better to acknowledge that, in this case, I'm wrong. And that's ok.

An Ecommerce Brand Is Constantly Reinventing Itself

A year or two ago I received an email ... the Leader asked "what happened to all of those COVID customers, it's like they just disa...