August 11, 2013

2008: Fix It!

Five popular songs from 2008:
  • "Low" - Flo Rida featuring T-Pain
  • "Bleeding Love" - Leona Lewis
  • "No One" - Alicia Keys
  • "Lollipop" - Lil' Wayne featuring Static Major
  • "Apologize" - Timbaland featuring One Republic
Fun times!

Your house depreciated by 20% over a two year span (with another 20% to come).  By the end of 2008, comp store sales were mired in a fifteen months slide.  The Dow Jones Industrial average dropped nearly 800 points in one day in September 2008.

A plan was hatched to fix the problem.  The Troubled Assets Relief Program, or TARP, would provide $700,000,000,000+ of support to keep the banking system afloat.  With 110,000,000 families in the United States, each family was essentially being asked to contribute just shy of $7,000 to make banks whole.

On Saturday Night Live, commentary looked something like this:



In the world of consulting, things weren't necessarily all that different!  Business leaders wanted consultants to "Fix It!"

Like in the video, it's easy to identify a problem.

In the real world, it isn't always easy to solve a problem.

I worked with a company that figured out how to Fix It!  They had a customer acquisition plan, and they had a merchandising plan that integrated with the customer acquisition plan. Combined, the integrated plan (no, not channel integration ... an integration of new customer acquisition strategy with a merchandising strategy) yielded significant growth during a time frame when the global economy was in meltdown mode.

On Twitter, you'll get a veritable plethora of advice similar to that described in the video (step one = identify the problem, step two = fix it).

In my 6+ years of consulting work, there is one common theme, a theme with three elements, a theme that consistently yields positive results.
  1. A strong (and inexpensive) customer acquisition plan.
  2. A strong new merchandise development plan.
  3. Integration of marketing and merchandising plans.
2008 was the first year I observed a company doing all three things well.  In the teeth of an economic catastrophe, as everybody else yelled "FIX IT", this company silently grew.  

They had a plan.

Today, we're knee deep in mobile, and it's retail cousin, "omnichannel".  Don't let lust for channel dominance delude you ... focus on inexpensive customer acquisition, a strong merchandise / new item plan, and integration of marketing and merchandising plans.

August 08, 2013

2007: Shooting Over The Audience

Five popular songs from 2007:
  • "Irreplaceable" - Beyonce
  • "Umbrella" - Rihanna featuring Jay-Z
  • "The Sweet Escape" - Gwen Stefani featuring Akon
  • "Big Girls Don't Cry" - Fergie
  • "Buy U a Drank" - T-Pain featuring Yung Joc
I left Nordstrom in March 2007. Six years, folks. Times change, and companies need an infusion of new thoughts - without an infusion of new thoughts, companies stagnate.

I would launch a new opportunity - MineThatData - with a presentation at NEMOA. I would introduce "Multichannel Forensics" to five hundred catalog marketers.

I had problems connecting the laptop to the projector.

I had problems with screen resolution, causing the top of each slide to stretch - causing the bottom of each slide to compress.

And the content sailed right over the top of everybody, gently gliding off into the ether.

As one attendee told my wife (who was sitting in the back of the auditorium - nobody knew who she was) ... "I sure wouldn't want to be that guy, he's dying up there!"

At the end of an uncomfortable fifty minutes, the individual who asked me to speak (we worked together in various vendor/client relationships for more than a decade) said "some of the more advanced attendees figured out what you were trying to communicate."  He never spoke to me again.

Big lesson, folks.

In order for the audience to understand what we're sharing, we have a tendency to dumb everything down into hopelessly awful sound bytes:

  • "A social brand is a successful brand"
  • "Brands not fluent in mobile will be dead by Holiday 2013"
  • "Omnichannel retailing is the future, and integrated campaigns are the path to the future"
Conversely, you have somebody like me - presenting content that flies into the stratosphere, when it should easily penetrate your soul.

These are the two mistakes we're making - every single day - dumb it down or geek it up.

The middle ground - sound techniques, solid communication skills, that's where change happens.

August 07, 2013

2006: Online Generates In-Store Sales

Five popular songs from 2006:
  • "Bad Day" - Daniel Powter
  • "Temperature" - Sean Paul
  • "Promiscuous" - Nelly Furtado featuring Timbaland
  • "You're Beautiful" - James Blunt
  • "Hips Don't Lie" - Shakira featuring Wyclef Jean
In 2006, people started asking good questions.  Here's one:
  • "If we invest a dollar in paid search, what is the short-term online payback, and what is the long-term in-store payback of our investment?"
Good question!

This question isn't easily answered by attribution algorithms, which basically did not exist in 2006 and wouldn't be able to handle the problem in 2013 in most cases.  Too often, attribution experts look backward ... they'd be better served by looking forward.

The problem was addressed via Online Marketing Simulations!


We simulated how customers acquired via search would evolve over time.

Customers, it turned out, would evolve favorably!

We learned that a dollar of paid search would yield:
  • $2 of online demand in the next two weeks.
  • $2 of in-store demand in the next two weeks.
  • A 3-1 ratio of in-store demand to online demand in the next two years.
  • A nearly retail-only customer within five years.
  • 50% of search customers were existing customers.
The combination of short-term online/retail demand, coupled with a huge long-term retail payback, allowed us to invest much deeper than we otherwise would invest.  Dollars formerly spent on break-even catalog activities were reallocated to paid search activity that drove future in-store business.

Retail folks like online activities that grow in-store sales.

The CFO likes online activities that have a handsome payback.

And the online division likes getting more money to spend on marketing to grow the total business.

It's 2013, and few retailers have the sophistication that Nordstrom had back in 2006.  Online visits were linked to in-store purchases.  The path from paid search to an online visit to a store purchase over three days could easily be tracked.  The information gleaned from an integrated database in 2006 set the stage for what folks now call "omnichannel growth".

Similarly, we have challenges in 2013.  We have to prove that mobile/social, to an 18-39 year old audience, causes changes in e-commerce, and changes in-store performance.  Who, to your knowledge, is good at illustrating this dynamic - not looking backward, but by simulating the future?  Leave a comment in the comments section.

By the way, you might wonder how we did this kind of work, back in 2006?  Well, we had a really solid information technology team.  This team, and members of my analytics team, wired data from our web analytics platform, our in-store clientele software system, order-entry systems, and retail point-of-sale systems.  In 2006, mind you.

We knew that our good customers visited the website three times a month, visited a store two times a month, and purchased one time a month, with 85% of purchases happening in stores.  When you know that customers behave like this, why in the name of all that is good would you try to MAXIMIZE CONVERSION RIGHT NOW BY OFFERING DEEP DISCOUNTS?  We knew the customer would visit our website every ten days, and had virtually no intention of buying online.  When this is your customer relationship, then you know that almost everything the punditocracy is selling is fundamentally wrong.

Now, if your customer has a 20% chance of buying again next year, then yes, you have to get everything you can out of every visit.  But when you know that an online visit will lead to an in-store sale (almost monthly, mind you), well, you market differently.  

Even back in 2006.

August 06, 2013

2005: The End

Five popular songs from 2005:
  • "We Belong Together" - Mariah Carey
  • "Hollaback Girl" - Gwen Stefani
  • "Let Me Love You" - Mario
  • "Since U Been Gone" - Kelly Clarkson
  • "One, Two Step" - Ciarra featuring Missy Elliott
Maybe you remember the movie "The End", starring Burt Reynolds (click here).  Wendell wants to end it all ... and then, at the last second, he decides he wants to live ... except Marlon (Dom DeLouise) keeps trying to eliminate Wendell (Burt Reynolds).

Well, the catalog-centric folks wanted the catalog to live ... but the decision had already been made.

I recall getting calls from the trade journalists ... "are you a moron, Kevin?"  They sat up on their perch, overlooking a pool of ad dollars generated by vendors, needing to generate page views to keep the ad dollars flowing.  Yes, they ripped us.  Those smart trade journalists who know so much more than people who actually run businesses, ripping us, telling their readers just how stupid Nordstrom was.

The catalog-centric folks knew better, too.  You could almost see the glee on their faces as July 2005 approached.  They thought they were about to witness an execution .. the execution of a profitable Direct channel.

Then a funny thing happened.

Within a few months of the termination of the catalog, sales INCREASED.  Across the board increases, folks.  Retail comps didn't suffer.  Online sales did not suffer, in fact, they more than compensated for sales lost at the call center.  Our reallocation of ad dollars from catalogs to search appeared prescient - we actually (coincidentally) timed a shift in customer behavior perfectly.

We experienced a dramatic reduction in ad dollars, an increase in demand in the online channel that more than offset the demand lost at the call center, and a dramatic increase in retail sales.  

The net of this relationship was an embarrassing increase in profit.

The catalog-centric folks had a very hard time with this.  Then they left the company.  And as always happens, a strategic change in direction resulted in a new Management team in the online division - one tasked with growing a pure online business in a retail environment.

My team went from 24 individuals to 16 individuals.  Yes, my team was gutted, and I had to perform the gutting myself.  We still had email, we still had 1,100 retail pieces to push out the door, annually.  But 8 members of my team were downsized, they left to work for the online channel, or they left the company, or I eliminated their jobs.  

It's not a fun process to go through, folks.

Not coincidentally, a new Research Executive was hired, tasked to do much of the same kind of work I had always done.  Remember, changes in strategic direction lead to the need for a new breed of Executives to manage the business.

How does something that happened way back in 2005 still be relevant today?

For many businesses, a combination of mobile/social will rout e-commerce.  No, this won't happen in 2013.  But it may happen in 2018.  Or 2020.  And when it does, a generation of e-commerce leaders will be faced with the same eventuality that catalog leaders at Nordstrom faced.

This is how life works.

It would be a good idea to start thinking ahead.  What does your job, or your department look like when a combination of mobile/social eventually and finally routs e-commerce?

August 05, 2013

2004: Error

Here's five popular songs from 2004:
  • "Yeah!" - Usher featuring Lil John and Ludacris
  • "Burn" - Usher
  • "If I Ain't Got You" - Alicia Keys
  • "This Love" - Maroon 5
  • "The Way You Move" - OutKast featuring Sleepy Brown
By the middle of 2004, the writing was on the wall.  Retail Management and the Chief Marketing Officer wanted the Direct division to stop sending catalogs to customers.  A task force was assembled to study the issue.

You know how these things work.  Half the room has a vested interest in keeping catalogs, because they get to keep their jobs if the catalogs are continued.  Half the room doesn't want catalogs, and their paycheck isn't impacted by catalogs enough to matter, so the decision isn't important to them.

By 2004, I was VP of Database Marketing - responsible for all catalog/email circulation for the whole company, a better job than the one I started with at Nordstrom in 2001.  So, clearly, the discontinuation of catalog circulation meant that my department would be gutted. I tried my hardest to remain objective, but my heart had to be aligned with the catalog, for obvious reasons.

It's good to be objective.

During our Anniversary Sale event in July of 2004, my team made an error.  They mailed the best customers a small, tiny catalog - while mailing the worst customers the big Anniversary catalog.

In the old days of catalog marketing, this would be a catastrophe worthy of getting me fired, and for good reason - it would have cost the company millions of dollars of profit.

But a strange thing happened on the way to the chopping block.

Phone + Online demand was barely impacted.  Instead, customers shifted demand to the assortments in the catalog they were sent.  Retail sales were not impacted by as much as a penny.

It becomes really hard to defend a catalog, when you make a terrible mistake and demand is barely impacted.

In the weeks after Anniversary 2004, our (my) simulations showed that discontinuation of the catalog might cost the Direct division 20% of demand, retail stores 2-5% in comp store sales, and the decision would have minimal if any impact on profitability.

Folks in the Direct division howled.

"If we don't advertise the item, how will customers know to buy the item?  Your estimates are silly".

Folks on the Retail side of the business laughed.

"We constantly kill merchandise divisions in stores, and replace them with more productive merchandise.  There won't be any impact on customer demand."

A decision was made.

We would kill the catalog.

Within a few months, the great diaspora of Nordstrom Direct catalog-centric employees would begin.

And we all awaited July 2005, when the catalog would be killed.  What would happen to sales and profit?

The error in the Anniversary catalog of 2004 should have given us a hint as to what would happen.  Folks who are watching the transition from e-commerce to mobile might want to pay attention to what happened when customers transitioned from catalogs to e-commerce.

August 04, 2013

2003: Stirrup Pants

Five popular songs from 2003:
  • "In da Club" - 50 Cent
  • "Ignition" - R. Kelly
  • "Get Busy" - Sean Paul
  • "Crazy In Love" - Beyonce featuring Jay-Z
  • "When I'm Gone" - 3 Doors Down
When channels go through a transition, odd things happen.

Recall the onset of e-commerce at Eddie Bauer ... a small number of orders, mostly for men's merchandise, while the catalog generated demand primarily for women's merchandise. In other words, the new channel served a niche market, while the incumbent channel served a mass market.

We learned at Nordstrom, back in 2003, that the same thing happens, in reverse, as a channel dies.

Back in 2003, the catalog was on the decline.  Younger catalog customers made the shift online, they were done with the catalog.  Store customers weren't terribly thrilled with the catalog either, buying as much from retail mailers as from the catalogs created by the Direct division.

Merchants noticed the change.  Catalog square inch analytics showed that the merchandise that "worked" was, increasingly, tailored to the needs of a 60+ year old customer.  And the best selling catalog item was a "stirrup pant".

Retail folks hated stirrup pants.  We knew this, because 60+ catalog customers would visit the store with stirrup pants in hand, ready to return them for a different size ... but the stores didn't carry stirrup pants.  Worse, the stores got dinged for the return.

Multichannel experts struggle with nuanced issues like the one we dealt with at Nordstrom in 2003.  Experts might ask stores to carry a style that didn't fit the retail assortment, to be fair to the catalog shopper.  Or they could ask the catalog to drop stirrup pants, and in the process, cause catalog customers consternation while hurting the productivity of the catalog.

What would you do?

By Holiday 2003, with all younger customers abandoning the catalog for the online experience, the creative in catalogs (and the merchandise) clearly appealed to a 60+ year old rural customer ... while the merchandise online and in stores clearly appealed to a 30-49 year old suburban/urban customer.

Customers noticed the disconnect.

Our Chief Marketing Officer (my new boss) noticed the disconnect.

And a whole lotta retail employees noticed the disconnect.

Something had to give.

What would you do?

By the way, this same issue is coming to e-commerce in the next five years.  As the mobile/social experience consumes customers age 18-39, e-commerce is going to be gutted from below, leaving an assortment that appeals to customers age 40-59.  This disconnect will be apparent, and dramatic, something that will challenge the e-commerce generation in unprecedented ways.  It's coming, folks.

August 01, 2013

2002: Multichannel

Here's five popular songs from 2002:
  • "How You Remind Me" - Nickleback
  • "Foolish" - Ashanti
  • "Hot in Here" - Nelly
  • "Dilemma" - Nelly featuring Kelly Rowland
  • "Wherever You Go" - The Calling
Ah, multichannel.  How you remind me of a foolish dilemma wherever you go!

I saved the Venn Diagram you see up there - it's from 2002.  Our paper rep brought this one to our attention.  I asked all of our vendors to visit for a day of insight - they all had to share something about the future of catalog marketing in an online world.  The discussion was stimulating.  I distinctly recall Abacus telling us that we had to do a far better job of integrating our channels, that we (Nordstrom) were failing in the multichannel game.

In fact, every vendor in the room agreed with the Venn Diagram - titled "THE MULTICHANNEL BONANZA".  Sourced from the folks at McKinsey Consulting, the argument was that if you could just get customers to buy from three channels, then customers would spend 9x more than everybody else, and the world would be a more profitable place.

That's all.  Just figure out a way to get a customer to buy from a catalog, online, and in a retail store.  Simply do those three things, and you're set!  Just get the customer to buy more often, and you'd be more profitable.

Oh.

So the entire retail world spent a decade trying to become "multichannel", while the experts beat the living daylights out of retailers for "doing it wrong".  Fun!  The companies that were lauded - like Circuit City, went out of business.  Companies like Barnes and Noble, with every possible advantage over Amazon, are struggling, while Amazon, missing 2/3rd of the Venn Diagram above, now owns 25% of e-commerce.  And catalogers, with 2/3 of the Venn Diagram present, lost significant market share to e-commerce brands who only possessed 1/3 of the Venn Diagram.

In other words, the experts were uniformly wrong.  Terribly wrong.  Wrong to the point of hurting the businesses they were paid to support.

I remember asking the room the following question:
  • "Which customer is better ... a customer who buys in-store 3 times in a year, or a customer who buys in a store 1 time in a year, who buys in a catalog 1 time in a year, and buys via e-commerce 1 time in a year?"
You should have seen the looks on the faces of the vendors in the room!  It was like a bomb went off.

See, when you rephrase a question, you cause people to think.  The reason the Venn Diagram above is so seductive is because it hides a key piece of information ... the customers who buy most often, by default, end up buying from all channels.  Channels don't cause the customer to be good - a good customer simply shops a lot of channels.

We did research in 2002, learning that, after controlling for purchase frequency, customers who buy from catalogs / website / retail stores were, in fact better, but only 10% better than comparable customers who purchased from single channels at the same purchase frequency as the multichannel customer.

0.1x better ... not 9.0x better.

And the 3-channel customer base was a few hundred thousand out of 7,000,000 ... meaning that there was virtually no impact on the business by trying to force customers to do things they were not pre-disposed to do.  You were better off spending money finding a new customer than asking a customer 52 miles from a store to buy in a store to become "multichannel" just to please multichannel advocates, never mind that it is terribly inconvenient to drive 52 miles just to shop at a store when the assortment already exists online, in the home of the customer.

This doesn't mean you don't ask all employees to behave in a multichannel manner.  Do all the internal, in-house integration you want.  We were able to show the organization the following:
  • Catalogs pushed sales online.
  • Catalogs pushed sales into retail stores.
  • Email marketing pushed sales into retail stores.
  • New online buyers purchased in stores.
  • Therefore, everybody needs to work as one team.
The message can be that simple.

Sell the message, not the lies used to promote the message.

And today, e-commerce folks are being inundated with the same nonsense with mobile / omnichannel.  Keep the lessons learned in 2002 top-of-mind, folks.

Oh - by the way - what happened to the productivity declines of 2001?  Well, there were consequences.  The individual who hired me was fired.  The Chief Merchandising Officer was fired.  I was not fired, amazingly.

By the end of 2002, a funny thing was happening.  Merchandise productivity was on the increase, the business (online+catalog) was at break even, and it was almost as if some bubble in the economy was forming, because store sales began to surge, and would continue to surge through September 2007 - an unprecedented era of growth.  Something seemed odd, but in late 2002, you couldn't quite put your finger on it.  I recall our Accessories Executive mentioning that customer had an unquenchable thirst for two things.
  1. Expensive Handbags - the more expensive, the better.
  2. Fashion / Newness.
Both were concepts I was unfamiliar with.  It was almost as if customers were starting to borrow from their homes to fund their fashion interests - I mean, where was this money coming from?

Curiosity and Contempt

Early in my tenure at Lands' End, I worked for a department head that had a level of business curiosity that was nearly unmatched over t...