October 18, 2011

Death Spiral: Core Business

When the core portion of a business is faltering, Management frequently tries to prop-up the business by extending into new product lines, and new channels.

Here's what a health situation looks like (sales in millions):



Bus 1 Bus 2 Bus 3 Bus 4 Total % Chg.
2011 $34.1 $13.1 $5.4 $1.6 $54.2 7.1%
2010 $33.4 $11.5 $4.6 $1.1 $50.6 6.5%
2009 $32.3 $11.1 $3.3 $0.8 $47.5 9.4%
2008 $30.7 $10.8 $1.9
$43.4 8.8%
2007 $29.3 $10.6

$39.9

In this case, the core business unit (business one) continues to grow, in spite of growth in other business units.  The healthiest businesses are able to pull this one off.

Most businesses, however, are not able to pull this off.  In response to stagnating sales in the largest business units, additional channels/businesses are added, and the results look something like this:




Bus 1 Bus 2 Bus 3 Bus 4 Total % Chg.
2011 $27.0 $8.8 $5.4 $1.6 $42.8 0.9%
2010 $27.8 $8.9 $4.6 $1.1 $42.4 1.7%
2009 $28.5 $9.1 $3.3 $0.8 $41.7 3.5%
2008 $28.7 $9.7 $1.9
$40.3 1.0%
2007 $29.3 $10.6

$39.9


This is classic ... decreases in the primary business units being offset by increases in new business units.  In total, the business is barely growing, and when you run a p&l on something like this, you're not going to be thrilled with the outcome.  This outcome can be correlated with a business that is entering the death spiral.


Now, if you have a product line that is in decline, and you are able to grow new product lines while the old product line dies (iPad vs. the classic iPod), then you have this situation, one that isn't bad:




Bus 1 Bus 2 Bus 3 Bus 4 Total % Chg.
2011 $9.7 $13.1 $20.7 $1.6 $45.1 5.4%
2010 $16.4 $11.5 $13.8 $1.1 $42.8 8.6%
2009 $21.2 $11.1 $6.3 $0.8 $39.4 3.7%
2008 $25.3 $10.8 $1.9
$38.0 -4.8%
2007 $29.3 $10.6

$39.9


This business responded to a challenge in 2007, and is now growing in total in 2010 - 2011.  The existing product line (business one) is in sharp decline, and is being replaced by sales in business three.


The middle scenario is the one we pay close attention to, when evaluating whether a business is in a death spiral.  Individual products or business lines are frequently in a death spiral, requiring new business lines to grow the total pie.
 

October 17, 2011

Death Spiral: Promotional Events

I recall being at Eddie Bauer, back in 1997.  This business was entering a Death Spiral, it's just that nobody really realized it at the time.  In a meeting, our Marketing leaders were asked to create a new promotion, a "multi-channel" promotion in stores, catalogs, and the website.  I recall that the promotion was not supposed to compete with other promotions.

I recall that the Marketing Executive told the CEO ... "We have promotions on 30 out of 52 weekends, what would you like for me to do?  All we ever do these days are offer promotions to customers."

When a business is mired in a death spiral, promotions are increasingly used to prop up sales.

And over time, the promotions change in nature ... starting with gift with purchases, then a percentage off a key item, then a percentage off of all items, then twenty percent off of everything.

Log all promotions your company offered during a particular timeframe, during the past five years.  If you observe that the promotional dollars you're giving away increase over time, it is possible that your business is stuck in a death spiral.

October 16, 2011

Death Spiral: Comp Segment Performance

Marketers can cover up a lot of merchandise productivity sins.

But you can't run and hide from Comp Segment Performance.

We've talked about Comp Segment Performance on numerous occasions.  I like to analyze customers who purchased exactly two times (three times for businesses with annual repurchase rates above 60%) in the past year.  I freeze the customer file as of, say, September 15, I pull out all customers who purchased exactly twice in the past year, and then I analyze how much these customers spent from September 16 to October 15.  This query is replicated for each of the past, say, five years.

When a business is in a death spiral, Comp Segment Performance declines.

Let's look at this example, for performance from 9/16 to 10/15:




Buyers Spend Comp
2011 10,339 $10.67 -2.9%
2010 10,593 $10.99 -4.4%
2009 11,334 $11.49 12.0%
2008 12,497 $10.26 -17.8%
2007 13,005 $12.48


First of all, you notice that the number of buyers who qualify for our definition of a "Comp Segment" is in decline.  This is a classic sign of a business in a death spiral ... the number of "good" customers are in decline.


Second, notice that customer spend is largely in decline.  Businesses in a death spiral tend to have infrequent, small productivity improvements that are followed by more frequent, larger productivity declines.  In this case, the decline brought on by the recession in 2008 is offset by an increase in 2009 that doesn't fully replace what was lost.


Now, crafty folks take this a step further.  They look at the promotions offered during this timeframe, and they strip out the impact of the promotion.
  • 2011 = 20% off plus free shipping (+35% to baseline).
  • 2010 = Free shipping (+25% to baseline).
  • 2009 = Free shipping on orders of $100+ (+10% to baseline).
  • 2008 = No Promotion.
  • 2007 = No Promotion.
If we strip out the impact of promotions, we arrive at true merchandise productivity.  You're not going to like what you're going to see here.




Buyers Spend Comp
2011 10,339 $7.90 -10.1%
2010 10,593 $8.79 -15.8%
2009 11,334 $10.45 1.8%
2008 12,497 $10.26 -17.8%
2007 13,005 $12.48


Now we can see what has happened to merchandise productivity over time.  When we strip out the impact of promotions, we have a business in clear decline.

This is one of the first analytics projects that are run by folks trying to understand whether a business is truly mired in a death spiral.  We want to understand what is truly happening to merchandise productivity over time.  In this case, merchandise productivity is down 37% over a four year period of time, and has been masked by an ever-increasing rate of promotions that erode overall profitability.

October 12, 2011

Death Spiral: Merchandise Divisions

Pay attention to the average number of merchandise divisions your average twelve month buyer purchases from.


Merchandise divisions represent a sign of trust.  You don't necessarily buy online and in stores because of trust, you do it because of convenience.


If you shop at Nordstrom and buy Mens and Womens, you do this because of trust, you're including the whole family, for crying out loud.


Measure the average number of Merchandise Divisions a twelve month buyer purchases from.

When this number starts to decrease, you're doing something wrong, you may be headed into the Death Spiral.

October 11, 2011

Death Spiral: Conversion Rate

Pay close attention to conversion rate.


Not for the nominal reasons you read about.  Instead, compare conversion rate and traffic levels.


A drop in your conversion rate is fine if it is paired with an increase in traffic.  Few people understand this ... you make changes to your website, and you notice that conversion rate and traffic move in inverse proportion ... that may be acceptable.


When conversion rates drop and traffic is flat, well, that's not so good.

When conversion rates are flat, and traffic drops, well, that's not so good.



Segment your file by existing buyers, existing visitors, and new visitors ... measure traffic and conversion rate.  You want at least one metric to increase, and you want that metric to increase faster than the decrease you observe in the other metric.


Decreases in conversion rate don't necessarily require you to focus on changing orange buttons to purple buttons on your website ... decreases may signal a bigger problem, one you have to raise with Management.

October 10, 2011

Death Spiral: Search

Pay close attention to search activity, especially among existing customers.


When your business is about to enter the death spiral, customers lose confidence.


And when customers lose confidence, they head to Google to compare prices, to compare brands.


Carefully analyze the percentage of search orders that come from existing customers.  If this percentage is increasing, and your new customer counts are within 10% of last year, it is time to hold a meeting.


Pay attention to non-branded terms ... you don't want a high percentage of these terms being purchased by existing customers, this means that your customers don't even understand your merchandise assortment.


Pay attention to branded terms ... if the percentage skews higher and higher among existing customers, it means that customers are losing confidence in your brand.


Use search as a signal ... a signal that your business may be entering the death spiral.

October 09, 2011

Dear Catalog CEOs: Steve Jobs

Dear Catalog CEOs:

A business leader asked, "What, Kevin, are you going to write about Steve Jobs?"

Originally, I chose to write nothing.  Then, a few thoughts crystallized.

Go back to the late 1990s.  Back then, Apple was in ruins.  Catalog Marketing, however, was on top of the world.

In late 2011 ... Apple is on top of the world.  The status of Catalog Marketing is frequently debated.

Think about the biggest difference in strategy between Apple, and between Catalog Marketers.

Apple bet everything on merchandise/design.  Macs, iPods, iTunes, iPhones, iPads, apps.  Could have been a disaster, could have been spectacular. 

Catalog Marketers frequently bet everything on "marketing channels".

I continually observe a fundamental difference in approach.
  1. Approach #1 = Create/Design innovative merchandise.  You can't guarantee that the strategy will work, but if it does work, productivity improves, allowing you to expand into other marketing channels.  This is a risky strategy, requiring gut instinct, intuition, courage, conviction, confidence.  We admire the winners, we beat the living daylights out of the losers.  We're like the chorus in a Greek Tragedy, commenting from the sidelines while others take risks.
  2. Approach #2 = Expand into other marketing channels.  This strategy is the polar opposite of Approach #1. Here, you believe that by expanding into channels, your existing merchandise offering is exposed to more customers, causing your business to grow and thrive.  This is a safe strategy, low risk, data driven.  This strategy is adored by marketers, analytics experts, consultants, and trade journalists, heck, just about everything you read is rooted in a tactical, safe approach to success.
Approach #2 will provide consistent, albeit tepid results.  You don't go from $75,000,000 to $150,000,000 in a few years by making your email marketing program more relevant, or by capitalizing on the long tail of search, do you?  But you are certainly able to protect your $75,000,000 by focusing on tactics.


Meanwhile, Apple went from being mocked to having more cash on hand than our Federal Government.


What we lost last week, of course, is somebody we can point to, somebody who didn't listen to best practices.  I mean, who would deem development of the iPad to be a best practice, given how other organizations failed in their attempt to create such a device?  And you can theorize that apps sprung the device into the stratosphere, but who determined that apps were the way to go prior to Apple?


The screams of the average plead for us to connect the dots and color within the lines, using primary colored Crayons.  They beg for us to focus on average issues, like privacy, paper prices, USPS viability, merge/purge rules, targeting strategies, the "long-tail" of paid search, free shipping, discounts on Twitter, Facebook Commerce, daily deals on Groupon, Foresquare promotions, email marketing relevance, you get the picture.  Every one of those things are important, of course, but none even remotely close to as important as having merchandise that customers crave.  Every minute we give disproportionate focus on executing tactics, we lose a minute where we could create and sell merchandise.


I remember being in "post mortem" meetings at Lands' End in the early 1990s.  These were spirited meetings about merchandise productivity, with merchants, inventory leaders, creative and copy experts, and marketers all discussing, without prejudice, how to sell more stuff.  No item was spared (feelings weren't spared, either).  We posted every catalog spread on a wall, color-coded based on performance:

  • Gold = 30% profit rate (profit dollars / net sales) or better.
  • Green = 20% to 29% profit rate.
  • Blue = 10% to 19% profit rate.
  • Red = Less than a 10% profit rate.
If an item didn't achieve at least 10% profit, then serious discussions were held about the product.  Is the return rate too high?  Is the gross margin too low?  Is the product "tired", has it been featured too often?  Is the item paired with other items that don't sell well?  Do we need new products?  Did profitability suffer because the fulfillment rate was terrible?  Did returns suffer because of quality issues?  Did marketing contact the right customers with the right strategy, or did marketing activities cannibalize each other?


Ultimately, we succeeded or failed because of the merchandise we offered, the service we provided, and how we communicated to the customer the reasons why s/he should buy it.  We knew that new products were essential to success.  We knew that "winners", certain product that performs well, had to be featured in a certain way, especially to newer customers, in order to maximize success.


When I worked at Eddie Bauer in the late 1990s, this discipline did not exist.  In fact, the difference in culture was amazing to me.  Folks cared about whether the 20% off promotion outperformed a Gift with Purchase promotion, or they cared about whether 10% off plus free shipping outperformed lower prices on items offered to new customers.  Or people cared about what impact credit promotions could provide in increasing sales.  I'm not saying merchandise wasn't important, but merchandise productivity was not embedded in the culture, outside of the merchandising department.


And on a comparable basis, Eddie Bauer sold about 75% as much as Lands' End sold.


It's this DNA, this hard-wiring of love for merchandise/design/creative, that I hope our industry doesn't lose.  Until last week, there was always a marketer that we could point to, an example for how to do things different.  


Who, do you think, picks up the torch and carries it into the future?

An Ecommerce Brand Is Constantly Reinventing Itself

A year or two ago I received an email ... the Leader asked "what happened to all of those COVID customers, it's like they just disa...