November 09, 2011

If You Want To Do Something Different ...

... then try this exercise:

  1. Put together a panel of 10 bright employees, under the age of 30.
  2. Give them one month to put together a one hour presentation.  
  3. Topic = How We Shop.
  4. Ask each employee to list five companies that they have purchased product from that is loosely competitive to the product your company offers, in the past year.
  5. Ask each employee to describe how they found out about the company.  Was there marketing involved, marketing that informed the purchase or even caused the purchase to happen?
  6. Ask each employee to list five companies that they "admire" ... these could be companies they buy from frequently, or it could be companies that they simply like.  How does this company interact with the employee?
  7. Ask each employee to describe how an ideal company should "market" to the employee.
  8. Ask the employees to produce this information individually, but to create the presentation collaboratively.  Pay close attention to how this team self-organizes.
If you really want to have fun, choose ten employees age fifty or older.  Put them through the same set of objectives.  Give this audience a full hour to present their findings.


Evaluate the companies chosen by each set of individuals.  Evaluate the differences in marketing strategy, in marketing channels, in tactics used to build relationships with customers.


After your Executive team reviews each presentation, have an honest discussion with your Executive team about the stark differences between the companies and marketing tactics outlined by each team.  How does this stark difference in approach impact your company?  What can be learned from each presentation?  How can the findings be applied to your five year strategic plan?


Thoughts?

November 08, 2011

Miles Apart

Give this article a read ... from Brian Solis at The Altimeter Group.

Now think about what you would write as a long-standing catalog executive, if you had to describe how your business was evolving ... would a single word from the presentation apply to your business?

Almost none of it would apply ... a 58 year old shopper doesn't act in the manner outlined in the article.  Sure, you can find eight percent of the audience that may act that way ... but not the whole audience.

And almost nothing about your paper would apply to the audience that consumes information from The Altimeter Group ... a 28 year old shopper doesn't act in a way that's congruent with how you market to your core audience, by and large.  Sure, you can find eight percent of this audience that may shop via catalogs, but not the whole audience.

Modern business models and traditional business models are miles apart ... miles apart in customer demographics ... miles apart in marketing strategies ... simply miles apart.

You could try to bolt catalogs on to social commerce ... it could work ... but it's not likely to work.

And you could try to bolt social commerce on to catalogs ... it could work ... but it's not likely to work.

The pundits tell us we have to do everything, they tell us exactly what the future holds (change or die).  It might be time to figure out just how many miles apart the pundits are from where you are.  If the distance is too great, it'll be really hard to change, requiring a different approach to chart a course to the future.

November 07, 2011

Free Shipping Will Be Mandatory

In late October, we talked about things that we learned in 2011.


Without doubt, we learned that many of us are going to be forced to move to a Free Shipping model, in the near future.


Oh, I can hear the moans and groans already.
  • "We can't afford to do this."
  • "We lose the ability to use free shipping as a promotion to goose sales."
Honestly, we "can" afford to do this.


We'll do this by executing two important tactics.
  1. Let's say that free shipping, no hurdle, gets you a 25% productivity bump.
  2. We'll cut marketing expense (catalog mailings), significantly, by 20%, by not mailing online-centric, social-centric, and mobile-centric customers as many catalogs.
  3. The circulation cuts will cost us a 5% top-line sales hit.
The combination of tactics yield a profit and loss statement that looks something like this:

For some of us, it will look like this.  For some of us, we'll lose a ton of money, but the file will grow, eventually offsetting our losses.  For some of us, we'll even make a little bit of money in the short term.

Eventually, most businesses will shift to free shipping, eliminating the 25% sales bump.  That's when things get really interesting.

In the next three years, we will begin the transition.
  • We will pay for free shipping by not mailing as many catalogs to online-centric, social-centric, and mobile-centric customers.  Catalog marketing will ultimately pay for free shipping.

November 06, 2011

Dear Catalog CEOs: Do Everything

Dear Catalog CEOs:


Have you had an opportunity to view this "infographic", as the kids call 'em?

The graph illustrates how music spread and evolved over the course of a century.  Pay close attention to what happens after 1980 ... everything accelerates, music is influenced by different continents and different genres.


The pundits will tell you that this is the reason you have to be "multichannel" ... they want you to "do everything".  If you don't "do everything", you won't reach your "target" customer.  Then, the pundits tell you something like ... "in these challenging economic times, brands that don't relate to today's sophisticated shopper across all channels do so at their own peril".


At their own peril?!


The infographic represents the kind of marketing environment we deal with.  We have to figure out where we reside in the ecosystem.  We don't have to do everything.  In the infographic, "rock and roll" just kind of ends ... there isn't a logical connection from "rock and roll" to, say, "synth pop", is there?


Nor is there a logical connection from "catalogs" to "Twitter".  We're told there is a logical connection, but there isn't.  All sorts of people figure out how to use Twitter to grow business.  Not many companies figure out how to connect catalog marketing and Twitter.


Every day that we try to chase channels, trying to "do everything", is an additional day that we failed to focus on merchandise productivity.  We're better off figuring out where we reside in the ecosystem, then capitalizing on our place in the ecosystem.  There's nothing wrong with growing a business on Twitter, assuming a scalable business can be grown on Twitter.  There is something fundamentally wrong with assuming one can connect the past to a version of the future.

November 03, 2011

The Life Spiral: New Channels

Businesses in the "Life Spiral" frequently exhibit a nice diversity of old and new channels.


Take social, for instance.  The average catalog brand creates a Twitter presence, then offers thirty-five or forty tweets encouraging the customer to take 20% off plus free shipping.  Predictably, the channel doesn't work, it is determined that "social doesn't work", and that's the end of the story.  Over time, a preferred channel takes hold, and the customer ages along with the channel.


Businesses climbing the "Life Spiral" experiment with new channels.  They simply don't focus on the "core business".  They earn merchandise productivity after seeding the business with new products and new customers, using improved profitability to experiment, to not rest on laurels.


Businesses climbing the "Life Spiral" prioritize experimentation.  A mobile initiative is not buried on the information technology "Book of Work" ... folks happily choose to build the mobile website, Management gladly prioritizes the new opportunity over the re-write of the COBOL-based order-entry system.


Businesses climbing the "Life Spiral" do not over-think attribution.  These businesses simply don't care if the mobile site fully cannibalizes e-commerce (see eBay), instead, these businesses seek to learn as much as possible, not necessarily trying to be industry leaders but instead quantifying how customers respond to new opportunities.


Businesses climbing the "Life Spiral" assign a purpose to a channel, choosing to not expand into new channels because a blogger or a trade journalist write an article.  A mobile initiative surrounds solving a real customer need.  Social Media is often assigned to customer service, not marketing, in order to take care of genuine customer problems.  Affiliate marketing programs yield customers that are assigned to outlet/clearance contact strategies, given the propensity of the customer to look for a deal.


When a business climbs the "Life Spiral", clarity of channels becomes obvious.  Every new channel is assigned a strategic place in the company ecosystem.  Employees are not demonized if a channel fails.  Sales attribution is secondary to the knowledge gained in new channels.

November 02, 2011

The Life Spiral: Merchandise Productivity

The most successful businesses I work with make merchandise productivity their number one initiative.


You'll know that marketing has bought in to merchandise productivity by their actions.

  1. Does your Chief Marketing Officer babble endlessly about his love of merchandise on Twitter?
  2. Does your E-Mail marketing team use your subject lines to promote promotions, or to promote merchandise?
  3. Does your Analytics Expert spend a disproportionate amount of time moonlighting on projects to support the Merchandising Team?
  4. Company chatter shifts from sales events to new product arrivals.
Successful businesses possess merchants who crave knowledge of how their products perform.

  1. They demand reporting that illustrates item profitability by search term.
  2. They demand reporting that illustrates sales volume within email campaigns, especially by customer segment within the campaign.
  3. They need to understand how much of annual sales volume, by item, is not driven by marketing efforts ... in other words, they want to know how much of annual item sales is generated only because the customer craves the products sold by the merchant.
These days, we read all about the "data driven culture".  That's not a bad thing.  But I'd rather be associated with a "merchant driven culture".


Businesses ascending the "Life Spiral" fuse merchandise reporting and customer reporting.  Vendors would say that this is all about "breaking down silos", but that's not the case.  Instead, it's an output of a culture where marketing and merchandising are uniquely focused on measuring merchandise productivity.  These businesses endlessly care about identifying ways to encourage each and every item to generate more sales.


Businesses ascending the "Life Spiral" evaluate item profitability, without prejudice.  Merchandising, Marketing, Inventory, Operations, E-Comnmerce, Finance, Human Resources ... all departments meet monthly, thoroughly evaluating the performance of every item sold.  Everybody talks about everything.  These aren't meetings where everybody produces canned reports and offers canned speeches.  Instead, these are genuine meetings where the employees are passionate about merchandise.


When a business ascends the "Life Spiral", all employees become passionate about merchandise productivity ... all employees cannot help but exude love for the products sold by the business.

November 01, 2011

The Life Spiral: Low Cost Customer Acquisition

When I look at the most successful companies I work with, I notice similar trends.

  1. A twelve-month buyer file that is growing.
  2. Annual retention rates that are not necessarily increasing or decreasing.
  3. New customer counts that increase at healthy rates, year-over-year.
  4. A diversity of sources for new customers, no one source accounts for a disproportionate number of new customers.
  5. Profit per New Customer, on average, tends to improve over time, enabling the business to expand new customer acquisition activities.
  6. Catalog Marketers offer Prospect Catalogs, smaller page counts with best-selling merchandise, enabling the business to significantly improve productivity and increase profit per new customer.
  7. Focus is on customers, not channels.  The goal is to find inexpensive ways to acquire new customers.  If newspaper ads work best, the business doesn't care, it simply expands into newspaper ads.  Magazines, radio, television, billboards, search, whatever the channel, the business doesn't care, it simply seeks to find new customers.
  8. A "variable budget".  In other words, the Finance Department allows the marketing team to spend infinite dollars, as long as profit per new customer meets a pre-established threshold.
  9. Twelve Month Payback:  Most successful businesses are willing to lose money on customer acquisition, at an incremental level, as long as the customer pays back over a twelve-month period of time.
  10. Customer Age:  Successful businesses tend to acquire younger customers, so that the average age of the customer does not age near the rate of time (i.e. each year that passes is matched with a customer file that is one year older).
  11. Full Price Purchases:  Successful businesses, unless discounts/promotions/pricing are part of the company ethos, tend to acquire customers who purchase at full price. Purchases at full price guarantee that profit will be generated on the transaction.
Businesses that are set up for success tend to exhibit many of these characteristics.  For 2012, set up a series of objectives based on these traits.  Inspire your organization to significantly increase the overall productivity and performance of customer acquisition activities.  After you experience success in 2012, get ready to enjoy sales increases that happen in 2013 because of the hard work you execute during 2012.

An Ecommerce Brand Is Constantly Reinventing Itself

A year or two ago I received an email ... the Leader asked "what happened to all of those COVID customers, it's like they just disa...