Six years ago I received my assignment as Vice President of Database Marketing. I was energized by the opportunity to put my stamp on the database marketing world.
I figured I could make magic happen, simply because I had a fancy title that demanded respect.
Within days, the cold reality of the business world humbled me. It would take a lot more than a fancy title to get things done.
Twelve thousand hours of work and maybe more than seven thousand hours of meetings later, I have learned how leadership and communication are forever dependent upon each other.
Here's an example of the importance of communication. Consider the following two statements.
Statement #1: We will be installing new campaign management software in April. Consultants will be here in March to learn everything about your job. These individuals will help us figure out how to be more efficient by using the new software in our day-to-day jobs. We expect some job responsibilities to change. Thank you for your patience as we work through this transition.
Statement #2: I have spoken with many of you about your job responsibilities. I have heard your concerns, and have observed the long hours you are working. In spite of repeated requests, management chose not to add staff to our department. Given management's point of view, I decided to purchase campaign management software, software that should make our jobs easier. Because each of you are so overworked right now, I am hiring consultants to help us identify ways to best use the software. It is my sincere desire to have the consultants work with us in March, to install the software in April, begin using the software in May, and have a more manageable workload in June. If this transition goes well, I expect there to be enough surplus time for some of you to begin tackling strategic projects early this summer. I'm glad you spoke up and asked for a change. What questions do you have that I might be able to answer for you?
If you listen closely to each statement as the statement is read, you are likely to develop a mental picture of what you think is happening.
The first statement is relatively vague. As a result, the employee will fill in the blanks for herself. If her questions are not answered by what is said, she is likely to make assumptions about the pieces of information that are missing.
The second statement, while not perfect, paints a picture that is different. There is more information. There is less room for the employee to feel doubt.
If there is anything I have learned over the past six-plus years, it is the importance of telling as much as you can to your employees about what is happening, why it is happening, and how the employee benefits (or avoids trouble) by following the direction of the executive. Communication must be followed up with actions consistent with the communication.
Failure to communicate leads to uncertainty, doubt, gossip, and even bad feelings. Failure to act in a manner consistent with your communication destroys trust. Failure to do both is simply not a fair way to treat your employees.
Are there examples of individuals you have worked with, individuals who are great communicators? What lessons did you learn from the communication style of these leaders, or co-workers?
Helping CEOs Understand How Customers Interact With Advertising, Products, Brands, and Channels
February 13, 2007
February 12, 2007
The Square Root Rule: Better Defined
One of the great things about the blogging world occurs when individuals improve upon your simplistic work, developing the concept into something better, something more useful. Many big analytical companies hoard ideas and intellectual capital. Others freely give, in an effort to benefit all.
Enter Friend of MineThatData Alan Rimm-Kaufman and his development of the Square Root Rule --- found on his organization's excellent blog. Please click here for a well-written exploration of the topic of understanding how much money should/could be spent on advertising.
Enter Friend of MineThatData Alan Rimm-Kaufman and his development of the Square Root Rule --- found on his organization's excellent blog. Please click here for a well-written exploration of the topic of understanding how much money should/could be spent on advertising.
The Fast Company Blog: Deleting Negative Comments
I've enjoyed reading Fast Company since the go-go internet days of the late 1990s.
During the past year, I've been an avid subscriber to their blog.
Today, Fast Company wrote about personalizing Kleenex tissue boxes. In fact, the writer was critical of the idea.
I found the criticism unfair, because Fast Company generally supports marketing innovation, promoting those who try new things. So, for the first time ever, I wrote a comment on the Fast Company Blog. I stated that I found it unfair that Fast Company pushes companies toward marketing innovation, only to then bash innovation when it doesn't meet Fast Company expectations. I did not use profanity, I simply used similar text to what I describe here.
For the next hour, my comment was listed first. And then, it mysteriously disappeared.
I guess my mistake was to criticize Fast Company. Maybe if I had discussed whether the actual strategy was good or bad, my comments would not have been deleted.
Now that I know that Fast Company does not encourage an open discussion among its loyal readers (a decade of loyalty, on my behalf), I have chosen to unsubscribe from their RSS feed. I'm certain they won't miss me.
This also causes me to feel uncomfortable about the motives of other business blogs. Who knows how often comments are deleted, all in the spirit of promoting a 'conversation' that is perceived to be open and honest? Because this problem also happened when I left comments with a Seattle-based business blogging organization, it could be more widespread than my naive mind perceives it to be.
Am I stupid to allow all comments, positive or negative? Am I stupid to leave comments on other websites that may be critical? What do you think the right strategy is, brand protection or open commentary regardless of the content?
UPDATE: 10:41am PST: A reply from Fast Company suggests the omission was part of a spam filter. Let's take them at their word, and appreciate the fact they responded to me in a positive way. Here's what they said:
Hi Kevin, Comments are never removed based on content. If the comment posted, then disappeared, it was inadvertently deleted. I'm so sorry about that! We welcome diverse opinions and would never remove something because it was critical of the magazine. I hope that you will re-post the comment. Again, I'm very sorry about the inconvenience. We get a lot of spam, and it sounds like your comment was accidentally removed as part of an overzealous spam purge. Best wishes, Leslie.
During the past year, I've been an avid subscriber to their blog.
Today, Fast Company wrote about personalizing Kleenex tissue boxes. In fact, the writer was critical of the idea.
I found the criticism unfair, because Fast Company generally supports marketing innovation, promoting those who try new things. So, for the first time ever, I wrote a comment on the Fast Company Blog. I stated that I found it unfair that Fast Company pushes companies toward marketing innovation, only to then bash innovation when it doesn't meet Fast Company expectations. I did not use profanity, I simply used similar text to what I describe here.
For the next hour, my comment was listed first. And then, it mysteriously disappeared.
I guess my mistake was to criticize Fast Company. Maybe if I had discussed whether the actual strategy was good or bad, my comments would not have been deleted.
Now that I know that Fast Company does not encourage an open discussion among its loyal readers (a decade of loyalty, on my behalf), I have chosen to unsubscribe from their RSS feed. I'm certain they won't miss me.
This also causes me to feel uncomfortable about the motives of other business blogs. Who knows how often comments are deleted, all in the spirit of promoting a 'conversation' that is perceived to be open and honest? Because this problem also happened when I left comments with a Seattle-based business blogging organization, it could be more widespread than my naive mind perceives it to be.
Am I stupid to allow all comments, positive or negative? Am I stupid to leave comments on other websites that may be critical? What do you think the right strategy is, brand protection or open commentary regardless of the content?
UPDATE: 10:41am PST: A reply from Fast Company suggests the omission was part of a spam filter. Let's take them at their word, and appreciate the fact they responded to me in a positive way. Here's what they said:
Hi Kevin, Comments are never removed based on content. If the comment posted, then disappeared, it was inadvertently deleted. I'm so sorry about that! We welcome diverse opinions and would never remove something because it was critical of the magazine. I hope that you will re-post the comment. Again, I'm very sorry about the inconvenience. We get a lot of spam, and it sounds like your comment was accidentally removed as part of an overzealous spam purge. Best wishes, Leslie.
February 11, 2007
The Grammy's Of Multichannel Marketing
On Sunday evening, artists received awards at music's biggest evening, the Grammy's.
Today, it is your turn to rebuke my recent criticism of a lack of talent in the multichannel marketing industry.
I am asking you to identify the individuals who are deserving of recognition in the multichannel marketing industry.
Please use the comments section of this post to identify individuals you have worked with, individuals who are worthy of recognition, individuals who may not get the recognition they deserve.
Name the individual, list the company the person works for, choose one of the following categories, and then describe what this person does that is worthy of recognition. I will publish some of the particularly enlightening commentary as individual posts over the next few weeks.
Here are the categories you may choose from:
Today, it is your turn to rebuke my recent criticism of a lack of talent in the multichannel marketing industry.
I am asking you to identify the individuals who are deserving of recognition in the multichannel marketing industry.
Please use the comments section of this post to identify individuals you have worked with, individuals who are worthy of recognition, individuals who may not get the recognition they deserve.
Name the individual, list the company the person works for, choose one of the following categories, and then describe what this person does that is worthy of recognition. I will publish some of the particularly enlightening commentary as individual posts over the next few weeks.
Here are the categories you may choose from:
- Merchandising
- Creative
- Operations (Pick, Pack 'n Ship and Call Centers)
- Finance
- Inventory Management
- Circulation (List Rental, Compiled Lists, Housefile Circulation, Database Marketing, Sales Planning).
- Online Marketing (Search, Portals, Affiliates, etc.)
- E-Mail Marketing
- Data Mining and Business Intelligence
- Web Analytics
- Information Technology
- Leadership (Executives who deserve recognition).
- Management (Directors and Managers who deserve recognition).
- Vendors (Individuals at organizations you outsource key functions to).
- Other (Areas that are not easily classified above).
February 09, 2007
Running A Business Without Discipline
We frequently read about the importance of "managing the brand", about providing a great brand experience for the customer.
In the catalog/online world, it is just as important to properly manage the fundamentals of the business, the 'back of the office' execution that can make all the difference in the world.
There are several elements that all must be executed in harmony, executed efficiently, for the business to produce profit.
Fulfillment Rate: It should be no surprise that having the right merchandise available is an important part of meeting customer expectations. Too much merchandise yields markdowns. Too little merchandise yields lost sales. I spent my formative years at Lands' End. They were really good at striking that all-important balance.
Return Rate: Businesses don't have a lot of control over what is returned. For instance, the return rate on a pair of shoes is very high. The return rate of an iPod is probably a lot lower. However, businesses can take steps to reduce the return rate. Quality control is important. Using text to describe merchandise is important. Color-matching is important, so that the customer knows she is getting a 'lilac' dress.
Gross Margin: Closely related to fulfillment rate, gross margin is one of the most important profit drivers in a business. Gross margin is the difference between what the item sells for ($100) and what the item cost the business ($50). Markdowns are gross margin killers. Merchants who know 'what sells', and inventory managers who know 'how much to purchase' drive a lot of profit.
Pick, Pack 'n Ship Expense: Businesses should invest considerable effort in running an efficient call center and distribution center. Overstaffing either center results in too much expense. Inefficient ways to store merchandise result in added expense. This is an area that really good businesses focus a disproportionate amount of effort on improving.
When a business manages these areas efficiently, profit falls to the bottom line. When a business fails to manage these areas effectively, the business must significantly increase sales, in order to pay for its own inefficiencies.
In the table at the end of this article, one quickly notices that inefficiencies cause the business to have to sell nearly twenty percent more merchandise to achieve the same level of profitability. Think about that. When a business is run in a sloppy manner (the example below is not all that sloppy, by the way), customers need to spend twenty percent more just to help the business achieve the same amount of profit.
Leaders need to balance the importance of 'brand building' activities with the everyday tasks of running a business efficiently.
In the catalog/online world, it is just as important to properly manage the fundamentals of the business, the 'back of the office' execution that can make all the difference in the world.
There are several elements that all must be executed in harmony, executed efficiently, for the business to produce profit.
Fulfillment Rate: It should be no surprise that having the right merchandise available is an important part of meeting customer expectations. Too much merchandise yields markdowns. Too little merchandise yields lost sales. I spent my formative years at Lands' End. They were really good at striking that all-important balance.
Return Rate: Businesses don't have a lot of control over what is returned. For instance, the return rate on a pair of shoes is very high. The return rate of an iPod is probably a lot lower. However, businesses can take steps to reduce the return rate. Quality control is important. Using text to describe merchandise is important. Color-matching is important, so that the customer knows she is getting a 'lilac' dress.
Gross Margin: Closely related to fulfillment rate, gross margin is one of the most important profit drivers in a business. Gross margin is the difference between what the item sells for ($100) and what the item cost the business ($50). Markdowns are gross margin killers. Merchants who know 'what sells', and inventory managers who know 'how much to purchase' drive a lot of profit.
Pick, Pack 'n Ship Expense: Businesses should invest considerable effort in running an efficient call center and distribution center. Overstaffing either center results in too much expense. Inefficient ways to store merchandise result in added expense. This is an area that really good businesses focus a disproportionate amount of effort on improving.
When a business manages these areas efficiently, profit falls to the bottom line. When a business fails to manage these areas effectively, the business must significantly increase sales, in order to pay for its own inefficiencies.
In the table at the end of this article, one quickly notices that inefficiencies cause the business to have to sell nearly twenty percent more merchandise to achieve the same level of profitability. Think about that. When a business is run in a sloppy manner (the example below is not all that sloppy, by the way), customers need to spend twenty percent more just to help the business achieve the same amount of profit.
Leaders need to balance the importance of 'brand building' activities with the everyday tasks of running a business efficiently.
| Profit And Loss Statement: Well Run Verses Sloppy Business | ||||
| Base Case | Sloppy | |||
| Demand | $5,000,000 | $5,854,500 | ||
| Fulfillment Rate | 90.0% | $4,500,000 | 88.0% | $5,151,960 |
| Return Rate | 25.0% | $1,125,000 | 27.0% | $1,391,029 |
| Net Sales | $3,375,000 | $3,760,931 | ||
| Gross Margin | 50.0% | $1,687,500 | 48.0% | $1,805,247 |
| Less Marketing Expense | $800,000 | $800,000 | ||
| Less Pick, Pack & Ship Expense | 11.0% | $371,250 | 13.0% | $488,921 |
| Variable Operating Profit | $516,250 | $516,326 | ||
| Percent of Net Sales | 15.3% | 13.7% | ||
| Required Increase In Volume To Achieve The Same Profit: | 17.1% | |||
February 08, 2007
Social Media Index: Apparel
Let's try to end the week with a little fun, ok?
Using Google Blogsearch, I queried how often forty-one apparel and shoe brands were mentioned in blogs, both ever, and during the past month. Only brands with distinct names were included. For instance, a query on "Gap" is not fruitful, as the search returns too many instances not related to the Gap store. The problem is much less pronounced with "Zappos".
For each of forty-one brands, I calculated an index that balances long-term blogging buzz, and short-term (30 day) blogging buzz. Long-term and short-term buzz are weighted equally. The results are in the table at the end of this article.
Here are the top ten apparel/shoe brands, based on long-term blog buzz and short-term blog buzz.
1 = REI
2 = American Eagle
3 = Sears
4 = Urban Outfitters
5 = Patagonia
6 = Old Navy
7 = Gymboree
8 = Liz Claiborne
9 = Lane Bryant
10 = Eddie Bauer
Brands that had good long-term rankings include Sears, REI, Lands' End, American Eagle, L.L. Bean, Zappos, J. Crew, Old Navy, Victoria's Secret, and Patagonia. Most of those brands sell a ton of merchandise, and therefore, may influence the total number of mentions in the blogosphere.
Brands that had good short-term rankings include Sierra Trading Post, REI, Liz Claiborne, Lane Bryant, Urban Outfitters, Bluefly, Gymboree, Orvis, Anthropologie, Nine West. These brands had "buzz" that exceeded what they had achieved prior to the past thirty days.
By combining long-term and short-term buzz, we get the ranking illustrated earlier.
Buzz does not translate to sales or profit. But it is interesting to see which brands had a lot of long-term mentions, and to compare that list with the brands that have improved their buzz in the short term. REI appears on both lists, clearly leading the pack.
What do you think, folks? Is there any validity to measuring buzz in this manner? Send me your comments, and let me know whether this or some other version of this is a worthy endeavor.
The Table:
Using Google Blogsearch, I queried how often forty-one apparel and shoe brands were mentioned in blogs, both ever, and during the past month. Only brands with distinct names were included. For instance, a query on "Gap" is not fruitful, as the search returns too many instances not related to the Gap store. The problem is much less pronounced with "Zappos".
For each of forty-one brands, I calculated an index that balances long-term blogging buzz, and short-term (30 day) blogging buzz. Long-term and short-term buzz are weighted equally. The results are in the table at the end of this article.
Here are the top ten apparel/shoe brands, based on long-term blog buzz and short-term blog buzz.
1 = REI
2 = American Eagle
3 = Sears
4 = Urban Outfitters
5 = Patagonia
6 = Old Navy
7 = Gymboree
8 = Liz Claiborne
9 = Lane Bryant
10 = Eddie Bauer
Brands that had good long-term rankings include Sears, REI, Lands' End, American Eagle, L.L. Bean, Zappos, J. Crew, Old Navy, Victoria's Secret, and Patagonia. Most of those brands sell a ton of merchandise, and therefore, may influence the total number of mentions in the blogosphere.
Brands that had good short-term rankings include Sierra Trading Post, REI, Liz Claiborne, Lane Bryant, Urban Outfitters, Bluefly, Gymboree, Orvis, Anthropologie, Nine West. These brands had "buzz" that exceeded what they had achieved prior to the past thirty days.
By combining long-term and short-term buzz, we get the ranking illustrated earlier.
Buzz does not translate to sales or profit. But it is interesting to see which brands had a lot of long-term mentions, and to compare that list with the brands that have improved their buzz in the short term. REI appears on both lists, clearly leading the pack.
What do you think, folks? Is there any validity to measuring buzz in this manner? Send me your comments, and let me know whether this or some other version of this is a worthy endeavor.
The Table:
| Apparel And Shoe Social Media Index: February 8, 2007 | ||||||
| Mentioned Ever | Mentioned Last Month | Last Month Pct. | Ever Rank | Last Mo. Rank | Index | |
| REI | 159,992 | 27,266 | 17.04% | 2 | 2 | 2.0 |
| American Eagle | 130,589 | 17,259 | 13.22% | 4 | 14 | 9.0 |
| Sears | 221,819 | 27,060 | 12.20% | 1 | 19 | 10.0 |
| Urban Outfitters | 27,626 | 4,502 | 16.30% | 16 | 5 | 10.5 |
| Patagonia | 49,700 | 6,602 | 13.28% | 10 | 13 | 11.5 |
| Old Navy | 64,590 | 7,952 | 12.31% | 8 | 18 | 13.0 |
| Gymboree | 18,430 | 2,860 | 15.52% | 20 | 7 | 13.5 |
| Liz Claiborne | 14,584 | 2,478 | 16.99% | 25 | 3 | 14.0 |
| Lane Bryant | 14,760 | 2,444 | 16.56% | 24 | 4 | 14.0 |
| Eddie Bauer | 23,582 | 3,142 | 13.32% | 18 | 12 | 15.0 |
| Victoria's Secret | 54,609 | 6,373 | 11.67% | 9 | 21 | 15.0 |
| Anthropologie | 16,302 | 2,358 | 14.46% | 22 | 9 | 15.5 |
| Neiman Marcus | 31,608 | 4,134 | 13.08% | 15 | 16 | 15.5 |
| Sierra Trading Post | 7,328 | 1,511 | 20.62% | 32 | 1 | 16.5 |
| Abercrombie & Fitch | 35,069 | 4,221 | 12.04% | 13 | 20 | 16.5 |
| L.L. Bean | 116,647 | 12,749 | 10.93% | 5 | 28 | 16.5 |
| Lands' End | 137,618 | 14,437 | 10.49% | 3 | 30 | 16.5 |
| Nordstrom | 44,558 | 4,981 | 11.18% | 11 | 23 | 17.0 |
| J. Crew | 70,282 | 7,708 | 10.97% | 7 | 27 | 17.0 |
| Bluefly | 9,681 | 1,521 | 15.71% | 31 | 6 | 18.5 |
| Nine West | 14,210 | 1,989 | 14.00% | 27 | 10 | 18.5 |
| Orvis | 10,180 | 1,569 | 15.41% | 30 | 8 | 19.0 |
| eBags | 15,222 | 2,010 | 13.20% | 23 | 15 | 19.0 |
| Bloomingdales | 10,601 | 1,470 | 13.87% | 28 | 11 | 19.5 |
| Saks | 39,673 | 4,283 | 10.80% | 12 | 29 | 20.5 |
| Ann Taylor | 14,544 | 1,795 | 12.34% | 26 | 17 | 21.5 |
| J. Jill | 17,713 | 1,976 | 11.16% | 21 | 24 | 22.5 |
| Brooks Brothers | 18,650 | 2,063 | 11.06% | 19 | 26 | 22.5 |
| Zappos | 75,526 | 4,978 | 6.59% | 6 | 39 | 22.5 |
| Banana Republic | 34,739 | 3,617 | 10.41% | 14 | 32 | 23.0 |
| J.C. Penney | 26,477 | 2,777 | 10.49% | 17 | 31 | 24.0 |
| Norm Thompson | 2,663 | 303 | 11.38% | 40 | 22 | 31.0 |
| Chadwicks | 3,101 | 344 | 11.09% | 39 | 25 | 32.0 |
| Burlington Coat Factory | 10,572 | 441 | 4.17% | 29 | 41 | 35.0 |
| Dooney & Bourke | 3,977 | 413 | 10.38% | 38 | 33 | 35.5 |
| Jos. A. Bank | 4,696 | 432 | 9.20% | 37 | 34 | 35.5 |
| Talbots | 4,885 | 432 | 8.84% | 36 | 35 | 35.5 |
| Bergdorf Goodman | 5,189 | 441 | 8.50% | 35 | 36 | 35.5 |
| dELiA's | 5,984 | 435 | 7.27% | 34 | 37 | 35.5 |
| Coldwater Creek | 6,562 | 439 | 6.69% | 33 | 38 | 35.5 |
| Lord and Taylor | 2,133 | 117 | 5.49% | 41 | 40 | 40.5 |
February 07, 2007
The Neiman Marcus Fashion Week Blog
Once you start writing daily blog posts, and earn the right to have an audience, you wonder why companies are SOOOO SLOOOOOW to adopt this form of communication.
So when a reputable company launches a blog, you open your eyes and your mind.
Neiman Marcus is hosting something that resembles a blog, discussing the events transpiring at Fashion Week.
There isn't a social aspect to what is being written. Readers cannot offer their comments. But Neiman Marcus Fashion Director Ken Downing gives his customers a glimpse into an event they can never hope to attend. His writing brings fashion and commerce to life.
Neiman Marcus customers are buying the fusion of the story and the fashion.
Finally, somebody in e-commerce is communicating a story. Somebody is finally romancing the customer.
Downing is channeling Fashion Week to loyal customers, who will spend more than a thousand dollars in a heartbeat based on Ken's writing.
To heck with the ROI of blogging, the IT infrastructure needed to do this, the public relations nightmares that can occur. In fact, to heck with blogging. Why not simply romance your customers for once?
Stop cross-selling and up-selling. Stop trying to avoid shopping cart abandonment. Stop the boring e-mail campaigns. Stop the generic discussion about why your denim jeans are better than twelve thousand other brands.
Start giving your customers something they can't get anywhere else.
Ken Downing is giving his customers insight into an event they cannot hope to attend. He's giving them a reason to purchase something. And that's why we all work for businesses ... we are trying to sell our customers something. Instead of trying to interrupt the customer, give the customer something, SELL them something. Use words, communicate, share your emotion and passion.
Thumbs-up to Neiman Marcus for at least trying something interesting.
So when a reputable company launches a blog, you open your eyes and your mind.
Neiman Marcus is hosting something that resembles a blog, discussing the events transpiring at Fashion Week.
There isn't a social aspect to what is being written. Readers cannot offer their comments. But Neiman Marcus Fashion Director Ken Downing gives his customers a glimpse into an event they can never hope to attend. His writing brings fashion and commerce to life.
Neiman Marcus customers are buying the fusion of the story and the fashion.
Finally, somebody in e-commerce is communicating a story. Somebody is finally romancing the customer.
Downing is channeling Fashion Week to loyal customers, who will spend more than a thousand dollars in a heartbeat based on Ken's writing.
To heck with the ROI of blogging, the IT infrastructure needed to do this, the public relations nightmares that can occur. In fact, to heck with blogging. Why not simply romance your customers for once?
Stop cross-selling and up-selling. Stop trying to avoid shopping cart abandonment. Stop the boring e-mail campaigns. Stop the generic discussion about why your denim jeans are better than twelve thousand other brands.
Start giving your customers something they can't get anywhere else.
Ken Downing is giving his customers insight into an event they cannot hope to attend. He's giving them a reason to purchase something. And that's why we all work for businesses ... we are trying to sell our customers something. Instead of trying to interrupt the customer, give the customer something, SELL them something. Use words, communicate, share your emotion and passion.
Thumbs-up to Neiman Marcus for at least trying something interesting.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
An Ecommerce Brand Is Constantly Reinventing Itself
A year or two ago I received an email ... the Leader asked "what happened to all of those COVID customers, it's like they just disa...
-
It is time to find a few smart individuals in the world of e-mail analytics and data mining! And honestly, what follows is a dataset that y...
-
It's the story of 2015 among catalogers. "Our housefile performance is reasonable, but our co-op customer acquisition efforts ar...
-
If you are a restaurant in Los Angeles, you don't get a COVID-Bump. You get to be closed, with no assistance from anybody. Good luck!! B...