May 09, 2017

Classic Analytics Blunder in Catalog Marketing

The e-commerce leader says the following:
  • "We sent a catalog to our loyal customer base, and the catalog worked wonders! Those who received the catalog spent an average of $11.88 per customer. Do you have any idea how profitable that is?"
I do have an idea how profitable that is.
  • "It's not very profitable."
Did the e-commerce leader execute a mail / holdout test to understand the incremental impact of the catalog on her customer base?
  • "No."
This is a common narrative in the past three years.

Here is what mail / holdout results tell us.
  • Mailed = $11.88 spent on average, eight week results.
  • Not Mailed = $9.01 spent on average, eight week results.
  • Incremental Value = $11.88 - $9.01 = $2.87 on average, eight week results.
On the surface, the catalog looks wonderful.
  • Profit = $11.88 * 0.40 - $1.00 = $4.75.
In the real world, the catalog looks ... ok.
  • Profit = $2.87 * 0.40 - $1.00 = $0.15.
Now, we can't expect e-commerce leaders to measure things properly when 80% of catalogers purposely overstate catalog results so that they can continue to mail catalogs.

But in a "data-driven" world, we need to do a better job of analyzing the "incremental value" of marketing efforts. So let's start doing that today ... it's not hard ... and it's FUN ... and you'll generate a lot of profit for your company.

Mail / Holdout results.

Demand simple excellence, ok?

Page Counts When Bifurcation Hurts All Other Customers

Yesterday we talked about the fact that best catalog customers (a minority of your file) deserve MANY catalogs that are merchandised with...