March 09, 2014

Monday Mailbag

Email me ( or tweet me (@minethatdata) your questions for our Monday Mailbag.

Today's question comes from Tim:
  • Kevin, Multichannel Merchant (click here and click here and click here) says that Macy's sales fell flat in Q4 (Nov-Dec-Jan) on a comp basis and declined overall due to weather-related issues. Don't you think that it is unfair to blame omnichannel strategies for sales challenges when we've had the worst winter in a hundred years?
Tim, I want for you to look at the sales trajectory at Macy's over the past six years. Tell me what you observe:
  • Year Ending January 2014 = $27.9 billion.
  • 2013 = $27.7 billion.
  • 2012 = $26.4 billion.
  • 2011 = $25.0 billion.
  • 2010 = $23.5 billion.
  • 2009 = $24.9 billion.
During this timeframe, sales increased at an annualized rate of 2.3%, right around the rate of inflation, at a time when e-commerce (which is included in these totals) is exploding.

Macy's, who called themselves "America's Omnichannel Store" last year, the #omnichannel pioneer, if you will, is growing roughly at the rate of inflation. And in the most recent twelve month period, when e-commerce is absolutely sizzling and omnichannel strategies should be at their zenith, the business was stuck in place.


Ignore weather issues - merchants and omnichannel experts take credit for positive sales when weather is amazingly good. Remember back in March 2012 when it was 70 degrees for a full month across the eastern half of the country? Things balance out over time, that's why you take a six year sales look (like we just did, above).

When sales increase, the experts take credit for it. When sales decrease, the weather is to be blamed (#climatechange). 

Overall, sales are not outpacing inflation at Macy's, the poster child for #omnichannel goodness.

Look at the facts.

Look at what Amazon is doing to everybody.

Think about why customers actually buy from your business (#merchandise).

Craft a strategy based on what actually works.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.

Imagine What You Are Truly Capable Of ...

This was the largest Elite Program run of the past four years. The run required an open mind, something that sometimes eludes me. What did I...