May 03, 2009

The Most Important Catalog And E-Mail KPI: The Organic Percentage

Last week, I received an e-mail from a loyal blog subscriber. This person did the mail/holdout testing that many catalog brands execute. This person learned that more than 70% of the business that you see in best-practice based catalog results analysis happened regardless whether a catalog was mailed or not.

This phenomenon is known as the "Organic Percentage". You execute a mail group and a holdout group, very simple testing.

Organic Percentage: Mail & Holdout Test Groups






This Other Website Total

Catalog Catalogs Demand Demand
Mail Group $3.00 $4.00 $8.00 $15.00
Holdout Group $0.00 $5.00 $9.50 $14.50
Increment $3.00 ($1.00) ($1.50) $0.50
Organic %, Catalog = (3.00 - 0.50) / 3.00 83.3%
Organic %, Total = 14.50 / 15.00
96.7%

This outcome is seldom if ever mentioned by e-mail vendors or catalog marketing vendors. The opposite outcome is mentioned all of the time --- we hear that catalogs and e-mails drive sales across all channels. This outcome is more common than the oft-publicized "catalogs drive sales to all channels" outcome we read about.

Almost nobody talks about reducing marketing expense and increasing profit because we are mis-attributing orders to customers who would have ordered anyway. The vendor ecosystem would be hurt if this outcome were published on a frequent basis.

In this case, 96.7% of customer demand happens anyway .. only 3.3% of the $15.00 is because of catalog marketing.

Quantifying the organic percentage is the single most important thing that catalog and e-mail marketers will do in 2009.

Acting upon the organic percentage is the single most important thing that catalog and e-mail marketers will do in 2010.

At this time, the majority of my Multichannel Forensics projects require me to greatly reduce marketing expense while keeping demand coming in at a high rate. It is likely that you'll be spending a ton of time on this issue in 2010 as well.

Page Counts When Bifurcation Hurts All Other Customers

Yesterday we talked about the fact that best catalog customers (a minority of your file) deserve MANY catalogs that are merchandised with...