May 31, 2020

Returns on a First Order

Thought you might find this one interesting ... this came up in a project a while back and it mirrors what we saw when I worked at Eddie Bauer back in the day.


First-Time Buyer Rebuy Rates and Spend per Repurchaser in First Full Year on the File.
  • Did Not Return Anything = 38% Rebuy Rate, $205 Spend/Repurchaser, 9% Future Return Rate.
  • Returned 1+ Item, Kept 1+ Item = 38% Rebuy Rate, $210 Spend/Repurchaser, 20% Future Return Rate.
  • Returned Every Item = 44% Rebuy Rate, $180 Spend/Repurchaser, 12% Future Return Rate.
Let's assume that each returned item costs the brand $10 and let's assume that each item costs $40 for the customer to purchase. Let's assume that 20% of future demand is consumed by ad costs, let's assume that 45% of demand flows-through to profit. Which customer segment was most profitable in the first full year?
  • Did Not Return Anything = $77.90 future demand, $7.01 returned, $1.75 returns cost, $14.57 profit.
  • Returned 1+ Item, Kept 1+ Item = $79.80 future demand, $15.96 returned, $3.99 returns cost, $8.78 profit.
  • Returned Every Item = $79.20 future demand, $9.50 returned, $2.38 returns cost, $13.15 profit.
Which customer would you prefer to have, long-term?

The customer that didn't return anything is clearly best.

The customer that returned everything is second best. Apparently your generous returns policy creates good feelings ... resulting in a higher rebuy rate with lower future spend yielding a reasonable return rate and 90%ish of future profit.

This dynamic comes up repeatedly ... not all the time, but often enough that I needed to share it with you.

You measure this stuff, right?

No comments:

Post a Comment

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.

Imagine What You Are Truly Capable Of ...

This was the largest Elite Program run of the past four years. The run required an open mind, something that sometimes eludes me. What did I...