November 08, 2016

Helping Out The Co-Ops

Our topic today is catalog marketing.

Over the past three years, performance has declined by +/- 20% for many ... some have seen increases ... but the overall trend is not good.

But catalogers can help change the dynamic.

Yes ... you!

You wanted actionable findings? Then try this.

Let's say you mail a 96 page catalog that costs $0.55. You have a co-op segment that you like to mail. Three years ago, here's what performance looked like.
  • Response Rate = 1.2%.
  • Average Order Value = $120.
  • Demand per Book = 0.012 * 120 = $1.44.
  • Profit Factor = 40%.
  • Cost Per Book = $0.55.
  • Profit = $1.44 * 0.40 - $0.55 = $0.03.
  • Profit per Order = 0.03 / 0.012 = $2.50.
You were happy with that.

Today ... not so much. Response is down 20%. Here's what the metrics look like:
  • Response Rate = 0.96%.
  • Average Order Value = $120.
  • Demand per Book = 0.0096 * 120 = $1.15.
  • Profit Factor = 40%.
  • Cost Per Book = $0.55.
  • Profit = $1.15 * 0.40 - $0.55 = ($0.09).
  • Profit per Order = (0.09) / 0.0096 = ($9.38).
Three years ago, we were generating $2.50 profit per order. Today, we are losing $9.38 per order.

The co-ops are not going to be able to fix this dynamic. Only you can fix this dynamic (short-term). So get busy fixing it!!

Step 1 = Smaller Catalog. Go from 96 pages down to 64, and filter out low-performing items. On average, you'll achieve 81% of the demand on 67% of the pages. Here's what the profit and loss statement looks like.
  • Response Rate = 0.78%.
  • Average Order Value = $120.
  • Demand per Book = 0.0078 * 120 = $0.94.
  • Profit Factor = 40%.
  • Cost Per Book = $0.40.
  • Profit = $0.94 * 0.40 - $0.40 = ($0.02).
  • Profit per Order = (0.02) / 0.0078 = ($2.56).
We're closer to where we need to be.

Step 2 = 64 page Prospect Catalog - only Winning Creative and Winning Items. This will boost productivity by another 10%, +/- ... and the story changes.
  • Response Rate = 0.86%.
  • Average Order Value = $120.
  • Demand per Book = 0.0086 * 120 = $1.03.
  • Profit Factor = 40%.
  • Cost Per Book = $0.40.
  • Profit = $1.03 * 0.40 - $0.40 = $0.01.
  • Profit per Order = 0.01 / 0.0086 = $1.16.
Now we're generating profit.

When we generate profit, we can mail this segment and other segments that we could not mail otherwise. This adds new customers ... and new customers protect the future of your business.

Co-op performance is not going to improve.

Catalogers have to change.

And the changes are EASY ... how hard is it to create a prospect version of the catalog only merchandised with winning creative and winning items? This is what catalogers LOVE doing. So just do it ... help your co-op partners out and they win and you win (which means your printers win and your paper rep wins).

So go do it, right now!!

November 07, 2016

Retail Love in the Age of Digital

When I worked at Nordstrom, I was a Vice President. And on the first day of our three big annual sales events, I had to work in a store.

It was my job to make sure stuff was in stock, and to make sure merchandise was presented properly. Under my purview, the display illustrated here was unacceptable ... it was my job to fix it. And if I didn't fix it, the department manager or store manager would walk over and hand my rear end to me as a lovely parting gift.

The Department Manager loved the presentation of merchandise in her department. She felt like the presentation was a reflection upon her - if it looked sloppy (as illustrated above), then she felt the presentation was a direct reflection of her lack of love for her department.

Then it would be 11:30am and I would already be tired, but I'd still be hustling all over the place ... and then a member of the Nordstrom Family would walk by and thank me for working in the store on the first day of a sale event.

In other words, the department manager had support.
  • A geeky Vice President of Database Marketing was making sure merchandise was presented properly.
  • A member of the Nordstrom Family walked the floors of the store to make sure that the retail experience conveyed love.
Today, the digital gurus hold the megaphone. They shout at my retail clients, demanding "engaging" and "relevant" and "personalized" digital experiences that they perceive will drive customers into stores.

Let's say that the digital expert actually causes a customer to get in her car and drive twenty minutes to a store.

What happens to the customer when s/he is presented with the pile of pants above? And what happens to the digital marketing guru when the customer is presented with the pile of pants above? The digital marketing guru looks bad - his/her metrics look terrible - it's "his/her" fault.

But it isn't "his/her" fault.

The digital marketer has every right to walk into this store and demand flawless execution ... or at minimum, demand that somebody love this store.

November 06, 2016

Neiman Marcus Sells Out Of Collard Greens At $66 A Pop


We keep reading about "economic headwinds" and "warmer-than-normal weather" and "The Election" and a "competitive environment out there" ... right?

And then somebody is selling Collard Greens at $66 a pop.

Here's the thing. The article says they "sold out".

The article does not say if there were 1,000 units or 100,000 units available ... and that's the important thing here ... by limiting the inventory assortment they sold out, and by selling out, they generated "free marketing" via word of mouth.

The omnichannel experts told you to have an endless supply of commodity merchandise available in all channels. And while that theory was being built out, the narrative flipped - and now you need to carry interesting stuff in limited quantities, forcing the customer to act right now.

No 40% off plus free shipping on the $66 collard greens, by the way.

November 03, 2016

Four Things Great Companies Do Well

A few days ago, I talked about having a unique voice (click here).

I thought you might be interested in what people clicked on.

116 people clicked on the Patagonia link.

43 readers clicked on the Crouchstrophobia image.

20 people clicked on the Amazon Style Code nightly online show link.

17 readers clicked on the Duluth Trading Company website link.

That's the power of having A Unique Voice - a differentiated Point of View. You knew to go look at the Patagonia link, because you knew they would execute differently. That's the point I am trying to communicate. By having a low-cost customer acquisition plan fueled by a unique voice / point of view, Patagonia build up enough awareness that when you were given an opportunity to click on a link, you chose them over Amazon or Duluth Trading Company.

And the honest truth was that I wanted you to click on the Amazon link more than any, because that link is easily the most important link.

Patagonia is executing well.

Patagonia is not discounting much, either.

Do you see how the Four Things Great Companies Do Well work together?

By having a unique voice that connects to low-cost customer acquisition programs, Patagonia drives traffic to a merchandise program that yields high numbers of new/winning items. The unique voice / point of view enables Patagonia to maintain pricing integrity.

All four topics are linked together.

All four are multiplicative. 

I realize that e-commerce brands have faith in #digital.

I realize that retailers have faith in #omnichannel.

I realize that catalogers have faith in #print.

We need to have faith in the four topics outlined in the slide above.


November 02, 2016

New Merchandise, New Customers

You've heard me talk about this topic about a thousand times.

I gave a presentation earlier this year to a catalog audience, hoping to get the attendees to see the importance in having a low-cost customer acquisition program. I bring this up, of course, because so many of my e-commerce non-catalog clients have low-cost customer acquisition programs in place.

But catalogers don't seem to want to move in this direction. Catalogers love renting names from co-ops (better known as a high-cost customer acquisition program). You cannot ask a professional to do something different when doing something different may mean doing less of what somebody loves to do. So I stopped pushing in this direction.

Catalogers have generally agreed with the new merchandise thesis ... no pushback here. The problem, of course, is the catalog. This is the vehicle to promote new items for catalog brands - and the vehicle is TOO DARN EXPENSIVE to promote new items that are not ready to pay the bills.

Can I tell you a secret?

I spoke with an e-commerce Executive last week. This individual told me that he is responsible for executing more than a thousand A/B tests on the website EACH WEEK.

Yes, I said A THOUSAND A/B tests per week.

That's how you find out how new merchandise performs. And there's almost no cost associated with the testing.

E-commerce brands executing a thousand tests per week.

Catalogers planning months in advance to put paper in the mail, no personalization, no testing.

Something needs to change.

Going forward, the catalog must be small, nimble, and only feature winning merchandise. That's where things are headed ... only merchandise that pays the bills gets featured. But the website ... well, that's where catalogers need to be executing a THOUSAND TESTS per week ... testing how customers respond to new merchandise, quickly iterating toward the best presentation strategies for new merchandise.

I work with companies that experiment heavily with personalization via A/B tests ... these companies tell me that their conversion rates are 15% to 50% better than when they go with a sterile/standard presentation to every customer.

Let's review cataloger status on key initiatives.
  • Low-Cost New Customer Acquisition Programs ... catalogers would prefer to work with expensive programs hosted by the co-ops. Tons of money to be had, few folks willing to pick the money up off the ground.
  • New Merchandise Programs ... catalogers agree this is critical.
  • A/B Testing Required To Drive New Merchandise Programs ... catalogers are generally not interested.
  • Personalization That Drives New Merchandise Programs ... catalogers are generally not interested in spite of 15% to 50% conversion rate gains.
  • Catalog Structure ... catalogers want to plan months in advance to offer new merchandise in catalogs, whereas e-commerce brands leverage cheap digital activities to promote new items. This structure is not sustainable.
There's profit lying on the ground, just waiting to be picked up, either through low-cost customer acquisition programs, through new merchandise programs via an assist from the marketing team, or both. Merchandising Teams must do their part, and increasingly, I am seeing progress. Catalog Marketing Teams are generally not doing their part.

But the opportunity exists. How 'bout picking up all the profit that litters the ground? You are more than capable, my friends. You can do this!!!! Now let's get busy.

November 01, 2016

A Unique Voice

Ten years ago, I said on this very blog that catalogers had to become media brands.

How did our industry do at fulfilling the prophesy?

Not well. Not well at all.

How did Amazon do at fulfilling the prophesy? 

Better than catalogers did, that's for sure. 

You've watched Amazon Style Code Live, right? RIGHT? If not, click here. The show streams live weeknights at 9:00pm EDT / 6:00pm PDT.

In a modern world, Amazon hosts a nightly online television show. Catalogers "compete" by all making sure that all catalogs from all catalog brands are delivered into your mail box on the exact same day each week, fully diluting the viability of your mailing because the customer just received 27 mailings on the same day. That's called "co-mailing" - yet another vendor-supported idea that sounds good but is destructive to the heath of your business.

Facebook is saying that 70% of online traffic will be video-centric traffic within five years.

Amazon has a nightly television show.

Catalogers put paper in the mail..

Here's what happened, folks. Catalogers lost their unique voice. It's gone. Well, not all catalogers. Look at a Duluth Trading Company, for instance. You might find their male-centric underwear ads offensive or gross or whatever, and that's fine. But they sure do have a unique voice, don't they. And they've more than doubled their business in the past decade. What has happened to your business?

Have you read catalog copy lately? Seriously. Have you read catalog copy lately?

Let's go with an example. Instead of picking on a catalog brand, we'll use JCP as an example. Look at the copy surrounding this flannel shirt (click here).

Hey. HEY! Wake up!


Can you see the difference?

One reads like a textbook - one possesses a unique voice. Which copy stimulated your buying bone more?

The catalog brands that survive will have no choice but to have a distinct, unique voice. If a unique voice doesn't exist, then there's no reason for the customer to step out of the Amazon ecosystem.

Catalogers ... why not reduce your catalog ad budget by 10% (you'll never miss the sales, because sales won't go down when you cut back on circulation to online-centric buyers) ... and then reinvest the ad dollars in a program that yields a unique voice? What would stop you from doing this? What would stop you from creating your own media channel? You love channels, right #omnichannel? Why not have a media channel?

I know, I know, you have a PR department, and they issue press releases and they support Cancer Research and all that. That's 1% of what I am talking about. And supporting Cancer Research is great, but it does not lead to sales. You need to sell something ... right now.

It's time to create a media channel ... your own media channel. Repurpose the content on Facebook and Snapchat. Advertise your media channel. Feature new items on your media channel. Have a contest next March ... pit the top 64 best selling items against each other, and have your customers fill out a bracket to see which will be the best selling item ... broadcast the items and outcomes publish those who have "perfect brackets" on your media channel. Hire writers with actual chops ... not "copy" writers ... heck, your "copy" writers are probably dying to do something meaningful. Let them do something meaningful. Let them program your media channel. Let your creative people develop content/programming that supports your key items.

This is not a campaign. Campaigns don't last. This is the development of a media channel, one that give you a unique voice - it gives your catalog brand a reason to exist.

What are the odds that you will implement something like this?

I know, I know. The odds are zero. You just want to get to retirement and keep the wheels on the bus before the co-op lists die.

It's time to change. Again, what stops you from moving into the future?

It is time for stale catalogers to create A Unique Voice.

P.S.:  Take a look at this image from the Duluth Trading Company home page.


You might find this offensive. You might find this gross. You might say that "you'll never ever do something so stupid, you are a class brand (but please, buy now and get 40% off plus free shipping because our classy brand cannot sell anything right now).

This is what having "A Unique Voice" looks like.

Obviously, you won't do this.

But there is a version of this that aligns with your "brand". So again, what stops you from having an answer to what Duluth Trading Company does, but in a manner appropriate with your "brand"? What stops you? Is it you? Is it your CEO? Is it your Creative Director? Is it your co-op sales rep? Is it your Marketing Executive? Please ask the person stopping you from doing something why the person is content with tepid sales and 40% off plus free shipping?

October 31, 2016

Pricing Integrity

Have you witnessed the blood bath going on out there in regard to pricing?

20% of Americans now subscribe to Amazon Prime. In other words, these customers ... representing more than 20,000,000 households ... let that one sink in ... are willing to pre-pay for shipping and handling a year in advance, with no guarantee they will even get maximum utility out of their investment.

I'll say it again ... these customers pre-pay for shipping without getting any products shipped to them.

Now let's visit Chico's.


That's what a catastrophe looks like. It's late October, one of the busier shopping periods of the year, and the home page is BEGGING the customer to buy something ... 50% off one item if you buy one item - get discounts to sign up for email ... just a complete meltdown, don't you think?

Chico's isn't alone, of course. A review of any catalog website illustrates the desperation that has crept into non-Amazon commerce.

I have analyzed full price and sale price / promotional behavior for the past ten years, more than 100 times. 50% off is toxic. TOXIC. The future of a "brand" is poisoned by today's promotional strategy.
  • Customers who are acquired via discounts/promotions are much less likely to pay full price in the future than are customers acquired via full price.
  • Customers who convert from full price purchases to discount/promotion purchases are much less likely to pay full price in the future.
This is bad, folks. I'm sure you have analyzed the issue as well ... right ... RIGHT? And no, I don't mean you analyzed an A/B test with 20% off vs. 40% off. You actively simulate long-term customer value, and you know the results inside-and-out, right?

It's bad because when merchandising tactics are fixed next year, you'll have the right merchandise and the WRONG customer. Your customer base will expect discounts/promotions again, and won't buy unless you dazzle the customer ... and the deeper the promotion this year, the more the customer will expect deep discounts next year.

It takes 3-5 years to move a customer from a promotional rhythm to a full-price cadence. Most Executives don't have the patience to pull that off and deal with tepid top-line sales in the short-term.

How can you avoid this problem?

Remember, discounts/promotions are largely a function of inventory position. If your business fails to meet budgeted sales levels by 20%, you are going to deal with an inventory situation not unlike nuclear winter. You have to purge the system of the rotting tomatoes sitting on the shelves.

Historically it was important to make sure that the customer was happy. You didn't want a customer to visit the widget page and realize that widgets weren't available. So inventory levels were tied to budgeted sales forecasts, hoping that sales would hit the budget and all customers would be happy.

Here's the problem. Let's say you are in a full-price environment, and you hit budgeted sales. Say you forecast to sell 10,000 widgets at $49.99 each, with a cost of goods of $19.99 each.
  • Total Sales = $499,900.
  • Total Margin = $300,000.
Now, let's say that business is not hitting budgeted levels ... business is off by 10%. Your Management Team decides to blow through inventory by offering 20% off. The dynamics change.
  • Total Sales = $399,920.
  • Total Margin = $200,020.
Had your Inventory Team "under-bought" by 10%, you wouldn't have had to discount. The story changes (again), if you had under-bought inventory.
  • Total Sales = $449,910.
  • Total Margin = $270,000.
In other words, you'd sell through your inventory, you wouldn't have a need to discount to move inventory, and you take home $270,000 margin.

I know, I know ... if sales hit budgeted levels, then you lose out on $30,000 of margin.

But if business is 10% below forecast, you gain $70,000 of margin.

There are three benefits to this strategy.
  1. You avoid training customers to expect discounts and promotions, protecting the future of your business.
  2. You protect gross margin dollars.
  3. You create urgency. If the customer does not buy today, the item may not be available next week. As a result, the customer is motivated to buy RIGHT NOW. You want to train your customer to buy RIGHT NOW, don't you?
There is one drawback to this strategy.
  1. If business is on plan or above plan, your inventory team has to hustle like there is no tomorrow or sales will not be maximized.
Because of the one drawback, almost nobody employs this strategy.

In modern cataloging, where co-op response is awful (yes, it is awful, face up to it) and sales seldom exceed expectations by more than 10%, the three benefits greatly outweigh the one drawback.

Urgency is the biggest benefit.

The fast fashion folks figured this out. By having virtually nothing in stock, fast fashion folks demand that you buy something RIGHT NOW or it won't be there tomorrow. Urgency results in store traffic, high conversion rates, and constant "engagement".

Meanwhile catalogers follow a vendor-centric playbook demanding full integration across channels and endless inventory depth ... a woeful strategy that results in non-stop overstocked positions that demand 40% off plus free shipping ... a strategy that fully devalues the catalog brand.

The path to pricing integrity isn't "competing with Amazon". That battle has been lost. The battle is with other catalog brands. Create urgency by not requiring an inventory position that aligns with your sales plan. You won't have to discount, and you will create urgency. In modern cataloging, urgency is a key demand driver. Take advantage!

You are no longer competing against Amazon. They won a decade ago. Catalogers lost. The battle now is to take market share from weak catalogers. You don't want to be a weak cataloger, do you? Good! Then it's time to change.

The Ecommerce Middle Class

Not "middle class" in terms of income. "Middle Class" in terms of value to a client of mine. If we go back twenty years,...